Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Both?

Antisemitism in Sweden is almost exclusively found among the Muslim immigrants.

Politically the left is a bit blindsided in the Israelic-Palestinian conflict, but that is another issue, as is the strongly secular society's discomfort with all deeply religious groups, including (very) orthodox Jews.



sort by: page size:

The leftist-version of antisemitism is antisemitism. In a study [1] done by the Institute for Jewish Policy Research (JPR) this becomes clear. On page 29 a graph shows the answers to the following question:

"Thinking about the incident in which somebody attacked or threatened you in a way that frightened you because you are Jewish – who did this to you?"

The answers are, to some, surprising. There are 7 countries listed (Belgium, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Sweden and the UK). In only one those countries (Hungary) "right-wing" political views played a majority role. In two countries (Hungary and Germany) "right-wing" political views were a bigger threat than "left-wing" views. In three countries (France, Sweden and the UK) "left-wing" political views were a bigger threat than "right-wing" views. In one country (Italy) they are identical threats.

Less surprising is that the biggest threat overall is neither "left-wing" nor "right-wing": in five out of seven countries (Belgium, France, Germany, Sweden and the UK) "muslim-extremist" views were the biggest threat factor, usually by a very large margin. The lowest threat came from those with "christian-extremist" views, only in one country (Hungary) were these a bigger threat that those with "muslim-extremist" views.

[1] http://www.jpr.org.uk/documents/JPR_2017._Different_Antisemi...


I have to ask -- why do left wing people have much less problems with the quite common Muslim antisemitism, than with Nazi antisemitism?

Israel, and more specifically the Israel-Paletine conflict. The Left tend to side with the people they perceive as weak in a conflict, and while during Nazi rule they were persecuted and killed by the millions, they're now the more powerful side. Being close allies with the US doesn't help.

This is, at least, what I see from knowing well a bunch of Southern European left-wing people, from social-democracts to communists.


Antisemitism, I think

As a Jew myself the majority of modern antisemitism I see is from Muslims.

This is the correct answer. The amount of anti-semitism shown during this recent Hamas Israel conflict in the woke left has been very worrying. We are likely to see a big resurgence of anti-semitism in the next period. It's more and more socially acceptable on the left.

If you support Sweden for ethnic Swedes you a racist / Nazi If you don't support Israel for ethnic Jews you are a racist / Nazi. Or so I've been told.

Remind me again which side is the antisemitic one nowadays? Was it the far left or the far right?

antisemitism. Really, I didn't notice anything. Care to explain?

As someone else who is ethnically Jewish I feel there is definitely an element of antisemitism in these protests. Antisemitism isn't limited to physical attacks on Jewish people (which have been on the rise and are definitely correlated to the overall atmosphere). What do you think antisemitism is and do you really feel 100% of the protests and the protesters clearly hold no antisemitic views? I would say antisemitic views are rampant in many middle eastern communities and some subsection of the protesters and their stated views reflect that. Either way, Jewish people feel threatened (including myself).

Where exactly do you see any form of antisemitism?

Anti-semitism is on a bullish trend in Europe. Since this is very controversial, I will let reputable sources state the main reason:

http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/david-ranan-wrot...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/theworldpost/wp/2017/12/...

https://www.ft.com/content/f8d5e066-e0ac-11e7-a8a4-0a1e63a52...


At least in several European countries there was a tendency to label any criticism of Israel as a state as antisemitism. This is the kind of antisemitism they are fighting. They do not seem to care about actual antisemitism in far-right parties, but then they broadly agree with them on policies such as how to deal with Arabs.

Anti-semitism or anti-zionism?

Anti-Semitism is mainly found in Western Europe, in Muslim dominant cities like Rotterdam or Paris.

I haven't seen much or any antisemitism from the left, unless you are referring to criticism of Israel's state policies.

Antisemitism is intimately related to the question of who is Jewish, and there is no consensus on this question within the various communities involved. Some forms of antisemitism are explicitly racial but a lot of criticism falls along ethical lines.

Religious , Sectarian, Anti Semitism, Political take your pick

Outside of the US context, but antisemitism on the left (and right) is reasonably common in France.

One report explained, "For a particular left, anti-Semitism is of an economic nature. The Jew is no longer the murderer of Christ, nor the representative of an inferior race, but the sovereign banker, businessmen. In pro-Palestinian demonstrations, banners bearing the inscription "Gaza the new Shoah" do not bother the far-left leaders present. The discourse of the far left is simplistic: Israel is a colonialist state and therefore a state where apartheid reigns and Zionism is a form of colonialism, colonialism is racism and Jews are racist and are like Nazis.” (PDF: https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/Religion/Submissions/...)

* [1]: https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/french-philosopher-left-wing-... * [2]: https://www.timesofisrael.com/french-jews-face-trinity-of-ha... * [3]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-antisemitism-prote...


Fwiw i bet you'd call me anti-Jewish in this context. Not because i believe it more strongly against Israel, but because i'm uneducated on this front and the big countries like Israel make the news more frequently. So if i was to have any opinion at all it's more likely involving Israel than other similar countries.

I suspect that's true for most people.

next

Legal | privacy