Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

One reason right now is that the US Dollar is high right now. 10 years ago the Euro was 20% higher, GBP was 60% higher. AUD was 5% higher(but getting stronger).

Despite forecasts I think in 5 years the USD is likely to fall back again.



sort by: page size:

I think the main reasons of the strong USD are: - it's status as world reserve currency - it's seen as a safe heaven - The US is still the most profitable market to launch new product - the US job market is still performing well compared to the battered economies of Europe where unemployment is starting to go back up

If the ECB decides to lower interest rates before the US Fed does, then even more capital will flow in the US because why would you accept a lower interest rate when you can get a better one in the US in the same asset class.

That in turn will keep making the USD stronger than the euro.


US dollar is pretty much steady against the Euro from 2016 levels. The AUD fall is because of our mismanaged economy.

The fall in US tourism can better be attributed to Trump trashing America's foreign image.


I can't see one single indicator to suggest that the USD isn't in a long term decline.

The only reason this isn't yet glaringly obvious to everyone, is that the Euro and GBP are also stuck on a downward trend.

Speculatively, I believe the Euro and GBP will 'save' themselves out of trouble within the next 5-7 years, whereas the US will practically have to reinvent the earnings foundation of it's entire economy before it can break out of this current downward spiral of excessive debt.


Useful info for guessing at the cause of this: the exchange rates to the euro, pound, and yuan are all shifting toward strong dollars and yet the real value of dollars is still plummeting.

Actually the dollar is falling as well (in real purchasing power) due to inflation. It's doing quite a bit better at the moment compared to e.g. Euro. One factor could be the increased interest rates. Why would I keep Euros and get still nothing when I could get at least a little bit on the USD. Also the war in Europe does not help their currency.

Unless you also imply that other reliable currencies like AUD are "crashing", that's just the USD growing again after living in hell since 2008. AS I said, there are some structural issues to overcome, but it's not like the USD is heaven on Earth: US debt is still huge and the US government keeps having silly lockdowns every few months.

Why does the US have to reinvent its earnings foundation and the EU and the UK don't?

I believe the US dollar is in a long term downward trend because it is slowly slowly losing its reserve currency status as the US is losing its economic predominance. That's not a bad thing. It's just a reflection of Asia becoming less bad economically, which is neither difficult nor surprising considering how bad they used to be.


Tl;dr anyone?

I'm guessing it's something to do with the US dollar being overvalued.


The dollar recently hit a 26-year low against sterling and an all-time low against the euro. Just about everything is pointing to a lower dollar. US growth is disappointing (YC excepted ;-) and is set to underperform Europe [IMF]. US rates are expected to be cut later in the year whilst the UK and Eurozone are set to rise. The UK rate is already higher than the US, normally a predictor of bad things to come. US inflation is a bit high which lessens the dollar's appeal as a holding asset.

The US deficit, still 6%, is depending on the sale of US Gov. bonds. Oil producing nations are buying, and so are Asian central banks because they want to see their exports look cheap in USD. (Doesn't China hold USD1.2 trillion?)

The dollar looks set to drift lower. If holders get concerned they have too many and dump some of their wedge it'll plummet.

Interesting times. You could all be millionaires real easily. ;-)


Not cheap if USD keeps falling compared to EUR. My income dropped about 12% since the last peak. Not that I'm complaining, but given the current USD circulation I'm thinking it might lose 50% of value in the next years.

Another reason, possible related to all of the above: if the USD sharply declines in value for some reason, its trade deficits with many export-dependent economies (e.g. China) will also decline and perhaps even become surpluses. Those who run such economies /really/ don't want that to happen.

Look at a graph of USD against GBP, Euro and Yen for the past 5 years. I agree with the general sentiment but this isn't a problem that is exclusive to the UK.

The uncomfortability with the dollar right now seems to be a combination of a short memory and political sentiment.

The Euro has been strong over the majority of the past decade. Yes, less than 10 years time. Remember that from 1999 to 2002, the Euro was falling with decent consistency.

The US Dollar has been a stable currency for a lot longer and the US economy has done well for a long time.

People are worried about debt, but it might not be that much of a risk. If the banks pay back the money that was lent to them, the treasury can take that money and destroy it and there's no expansion of the money supply beyond a short stop-gap. Likewise, if they pay back the money with interest (and there's little chance this won't be the case), the US government can gain funds as well as not expanding the money supply.

The perception has changed a little, but not drastically with those devoid of political intent. Sure, part of it is that the Bush administration played loose with the currency and, in fact, sometimes argued for a weaker dollar and the current wars make the US look less of a good investment, but part of it is definitely political. I mean, if you're China you sure want to create the perception that the US won't be the continuing standard. If nothing else, it's like having two parts suppliers even if you don't consider one of them to be a serious option - you can always use them as a negotiating chip with the supplier you do consider a serious option even if it's a hollow threat. Likewise, many European politicians would like to consider their power rising; Iranian officials love to blast the US; people opposed to the wars want to play the debt card; etc. And some of it is legitimate, but some of it is FUD. I mean, if I came on here and said, "Linux just doesn't do graphics" there's a bit of truth there in that graphics card drivers might not come out as quickly or be as optimized, but it's not like you can't have a nice GUI or use the GIMP or whatnot, but I can say "truthful" things that are completely misleading because I want to advance an anti-Linux agenda. And the same is true here, one can say that the treasury (doubled|tripled|whatnot) the debt and not talk about how most of that is being repaid and it doesn't look like there's much of a chance it won't be repaid. It's the "truth", but it's still misleading. And if you have an agenda, those truths are your friend. Again, not to say that there aren't problems, just to say that some people might be pushing those problems out of proportion to advance an untrue agenda.

Oh, and one thing is important to note: government debt doesn't need to be financed. It does in the long-run, but not in the short term. A government with its own currency has the option to print money. When a government just prints money, it can cause inflation since if each dollar is a fraction of the economy as a whole and there are now more dollars, each dollar is a smaller fraction of the economy. Now, I say "can" there, because there isn't some automatic mechanism - it's based on people's perceptions. In fact, inflation can happen even without an expansion of the money supply simply based on people's fear that inflation should be happening.

And it looks like the "exploding debt" will only be short term as many of the banks have already repaid their loans.

You can try betting on hoarding food or whatnot, but you're most likely going to turn out wrong. It's not that other nations are "tied" to us so much as the US is still a very good economy. Plus, US debt isn't so bad. As of 2008, it was at ~38% of GDP. Compare that with Japan at ~172% of GDP and you can see that many countries do live with a lot more debt (Italy 105%; Greece 97%; Egypt 86%; Israel 76%; Canada 63%; France 68%; Germany 66%. . .). And as long as all the TARP money comes back to the government, there hasn't been any real expansion of the debt - it was a short term loan that looks like it'll be repaid quickly if it hasn't been repaid already.

Now, there are challenges. Rising healthcare and third level education costs in the US don't look good for long-term competitiveness, but one of those looks to be on the docket at present and it's easy to forget many of the problems that European countries have when one isn't resident there. But the US economy is far from a tale of doom. Challenges will be ever present - what matters is whether you address them or not and whether you do so consistently. And the US has faced up to challenges over a long period of time.

//That said, bonds are a terrible investment as you can usually get better rates in a CD from a bank.


Inflation might play a part in this. USD is worth half of what it was in the 90s.

Simple reason: money printing by the government. The loss of value of the USD is likely continuing if the aggressive printing goes on.

comparingly to more stable currencies like CHF the USD is loosing value since the last election, just fastening over the last months and weeks.

Some people have a hard time seeing their own currency it a broader light it seems.


Americans worry about the dollar going to zero, meanwhile it was recently at a 20-year high against the euro, the pound, and the yen.

Inflation has dipped to 5% and unemployment is lower than in decades.

For all its faults, American monetary policy has been better than that of most other developed countries. The ECB went 11 years without raising interest rates.


This isn't about the Euro. Yen is at a 20 year low as well, and pretty much all other currencies are soft too. Its dollar strength, interest rates in USD are much higher and going up (for now).

That's happening to a lot of US companies that do a lot of their business in the EU/EUR zone and other currencies that are weakening relative to the strong USD.
next

Legal | privacy