Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Sorry, I didn't notice this. I was talking about the comment thread in the external website. I didn't specify because at the time the sleeper nazi accounts hadn't yet activated here.


sort by: page size:

> recommendation algorithm started showing me neo-Nazi posts

Really? That seems... unlikely. Is it possible that your bar for “Nazi” is screwed to include things someone right of center would think are just normal values? Because I’m guessing you saw BUILD THAT WALL posts and AR-15 Competition pictures and not swasticas and lynched black men.


It's because you say "they" are extremist without saying who you actually are talking about.

Then you start a new comment with "These same people are calling others Nazi"

Who? When? Where?


/r/nazi was removed because it promoted Nazism.

It is just neo-Nazis brigading the thread. I wouldn't worry.

So .001 * .78 or, .00078 of comments mention nazis.

The rest of the world hasn't really moved on. By the way, new account, creeping nazi apologism, oblique (but not really) references to the jews... do you people have some kind of bot warning you of certain keywords being used?

I recall a thread from last year that immediately summoned a bunch of nazi propagandists, too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13704300


"Has a lot of nazis"?? Do you have proof of this? (I mean I don't doubt that there is someone who does since the site has a pretty big user base and doesn't censor speech, let alone speakers for opinions but...)

>These same people are calling others Nazis for sharing non-radical ideas with conservative parties.

Who? The CCC or Zwiebelfreunde?

Can you give me a link?

Edit: Oh, you are the one with the flagged comment in this thread.


Reading further, seems that the CTO of the project wasn't aware of this. [0]

But I cannot see anything done further here, and not sure if this means all members of the session project are nazis.

[0] https://nitter.42l.fr/JefferysKee/status/1281585770252230658...


...I literally addressed this two comments prior:

"There's a difference between supporting nazism and choosing to honor a nazi, sure, but we shouldn't do either."

Using von Braun's name isn't "honoring nazi action", but it is honoring a nazi. Not sure where this isn't connecting with you.


I think the other replies are correct, and this is nothing to be alarmed about. But I don't think you should be downvoted just for asking. Nazis are using new dogwhistles all the time, and infiltrating forums like HN. I don't blame you for having your guard up.

>I did nazi that coming

is the only one I associate with reddit in particular.


It's not the equivalent of being a nazi and I don't think anyone's perception was "We have to ban these literally goose stepping nazi's from our reddit website"

The just saw exactly what you described. Edgy trolls posting nazi stuff.


You are linking to a website that now allows far-right posters, not sure if Nazis are included. Did it become a Nazi bar? I don't think so.

I never once in my life imagined that one of the first comments on a front-page HN post would be one that claimed that refusing service to Nazis was "spurious" and "bigoted" and that said comment was not flagged-to-oblivion.

For anyone reading this thread, please know that this is NOT the majority opinion within the tech industry - not by a long shot. We are not Nazi sympathizers, and we do not think this is normal. It's not normal.


A. I wasn’t the one who broached the topic of nazis

B. This is a comment page about censorship and this thread in particular is about one party trying to end open society

So nazis are a natural comparison, and the valid comparison was attempted to be censored and avoided by bringing up an internet meme in exactly the way the originator has criticized. But hey knowing the meme is a get out of jail free card, no civil discourse needed!

Just admit that the comment would have been a valid defense of the nazi party in its ramp up. No meme-ing out of that and there’s been no attempt to deny it, just distract from it.


HN has literal nazis (as in "death to all jews") occasionally posting. We aren't special

Your comment actually is a perfect example of why this anonymity is needed.

I read the article, I thought it was an interesting idea. On the other hand, you (presumably) read the article, came to the conclusion that Nazis must be behind it, and have now voiced your concern that it's a Nazi scheme publicly on the internet for everyone to see. Some people prefer not to have such accusations thrown at them for merely suggesting innocuous not-politically-motivated things.


Would you please stop posting inflammatory, unsubstantive comments? Nitpicking plus Nazis equals particularly pointless.

Edit: you've been posting a lot of flamewar comments lately (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18620146), and we've already asked you not to. If you keep doing it, we're going to ban your account.

next

Legal | privacy