Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Where's the evidence for this? This answer (https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070607071114A...) suggests slavery persisted long beyond 477.


sort by: page size:

Slavery lasted for 400yrs(+).

Your arguments seem misleading - the existence of anatomically modern humans goes back roughly 200,000 years, but human history, i.e. the era with documented evidence starts with widespread writing that comes much, much later; first samples of writing is from ~5000 BC, but they're sparse enough to not be informative about social practices.

The very first documented law codes (2100–2050 BCE https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_Ur-Nammu ) already mention slavery. We can't know how long slavery existed before that, since those are literally prehistoric times and archeological evidence is not sufficient to determine these relationships, however, as the current evidence shows that slavery existed for as long as we have documented form of anything, there's absolutely no reason to assume that for the 200,000 years slavery didn't exist and good reason to assume that it did exist for at least part (or even all) of that undocumented time, as in the absence of any other evidence it would be prudent to assume that civilization at 10,000 BC had similar practices as it did in 2000 BC instead of being significantly different for no good reason from all other documented human history - we have no historical evidence at all of a time in early human history without slavery.


Look at you, knowing things!

...you understand that slavery also existed 300 years ago, right?


Slavery is a story older than history too. Just because it is old and ongoing doesn't mean we should ignore it.

Slavery never vanished. It was just extended to all races.

Maybe it was based on the number of slaves. It hasn't been for 150 years, though, so... what's your point?

wow, slavery is still alive.

Still, I would think more people are against slavery today than 500 years ago, which was the main point.

* Slavery

Slavery is still practiced in the United States.

Sure, it is likely that slaves lived there. But I would not state it as a fact.

Only if "survived under current conditions" is the ultimate test of something's worth.

Until 1850s slavery had also survived as a practice. But then it wasn't...


Read your history, slavery in america started in the early 1600s. That's almost 400 years ago. That's almost 6 lifetimes. That agrees with my statements.

I provided a source that says there were more considerations than slavery. Can you please provide a legitimate source that proves otherwise?

You're only proving my point, really. The only things you can think of are Confederate flags and the trans-Atlantic slave trade, when slavery as an institution is as old as human civilization itself (and continues on well to this day).

Incidentally, filicide is also ancient and ongoing.


Actually it's quite accurate.

It appears that you have an extremely poor understanding of the history of slavery - limited the US only.

It's universally understood that slavery was happening over 10,000 years before the US was even discovered.

The term "slave" even predates the discovery of the US by hundreds of years.

Slavery has manifested itself in many ways throughout history, I'm sure one could make an argument that this is some kind of modern day voluntary slavery.


Slavery was legal at some point.

And slavery didn't bother people 200 years ago. What is your point?

This would be a great argument to defend slavery in the 1800's.
next

Legal | privacy