Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Same. Most of the tech seems to not relate to actual blockchain use and instead talks about 'temporary authorisation of access' and data logging.

If someone does understand what Porsche is doing here with blockchain, please translate...



sort by: page size:

Yeah it's not really clear what exactly is happening or what blockchain has to do with it at all.

Yes, seems like this isn't the best use-case for blockchain technology.

Indeed. While I understand how blockchain works from a technical perspective, I have yet to hear an application of it that actually makes a lot of sense to me.

So this is not really blockchain tech right?

Sounds similar to crypto-talk: "but you don't understand, it's based on blockchain". It doesn't matter what technology is used, but what action is done.

"Explaining why he is using a blockchain at all, Stöcker says because the “future of business will be fuelled by the #MachineEconomy … Machines – such as autonomous cars.”"

So it's just for PR. No reasonable explanation at all.


It's pretty much par for the course for blockchain bullshit. They promise the world but aren't honest about the limitations of the tech. Yeah, you get data integrity assurance within the blockchain, but that says nothing about the accuracy of that data as it's coming in.

well, that's weird because according to the institute that runs the entire thing (https://www.niis.org/blog/2018/4/26/there-is-no-blockchain-t...), there is no blockchain technology involved, it merely uses some hashes to link data together, as do plenty of age-old protocols.

This is a good example of why these PR campaigns are silly.


It doesn't use a blockchain, the headline is misleading.

It's just car charging where you pay using Ethereum.


Hmm what they actually seem to be doing here is using the blockchain technology, not a bitcoin like currency.

I am a regular and boistrous cheerleader for the prospects of blockchain technologies to empower changes in the world... but I do not understand what is going on here.

This seems entirely centralized, and thus a very poor use case for a blockchain.


I don't believe this for one minute. I don't think "the blockchain" is useful for anything other than revision control.

I'm always on the lookout for an interesting criticism of blockchain technology, this isn't one of them.

That sounds to me like someone used excitement about "blockchain" as an excuse to upgrade a two-decades old system to something a bit more modern.

It looks like it's a private blockchain shared between two (at the moment institutions), which means it's probably being used basically as an append-only log.


I completely agree. It's almost like blockchains are only useful for trustless decentralized systems.

So far the only real use of blockchain technology is Git. Cryptocurrencies are misuse of it :-D

I’m unable to find a single article that actually details what “blockchain technology” they’re using, and why. Every English article seems to be a rehash of the same press release - Can anybody find something better in mandarin ?

they are just trying to make it like blockchain is not a big deal, hey we all have blockchain, saw it in an interview too.

This reminds me of a previous job. The management—none of which were technical people—just loved the idea of investigating “the blockchain” and “IoT” and “machine learning” and “AI”, but had no clue what it meant. I left after a couple of months.

Has anyone else read this article and had the same experience as me? I genuinely second guess myself when reading it: have I lost the ability to read? Am I stupid? I read all these words on the page yet I have absolutely no comprehension of what was said. What on Earth was written on the “formalising humans on the blockchain” section for example? There sure are a lot of words, but nothing actually got said.

What, exactly do they want to do with a blockchain and why? It’s a simple question.

Oh, they have some cryptocurrency token they want to sell. Gotcha.

next

Legal | privacy