Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Huh, I just looked it up, I guess the Mayor represents the five burroughs but you'd think Kings, Queens, Manhattan, the Bronx, and Staten Island would have representatives that represent them alone if Nassau, Rockland, Putnam, and Orange counties do.

Bizarre.



sort by: page size:

New York City, which is implementing this, is a bit of a weird case in that it actually sits above the counties, not below them. New York's five boroughs are technically five counties.

Nitpick, but NYC is not inside of a county: five counties are inside of it.

Doesn't change your point, though.


And each county is a borough.

New York = Manhattan

Kings = Brooklyn

Bronx = The Bronx

Queens = Queens

Richmond = Staten Island

Just to keep things extra complicated...


I don't think NYC does. Nassau County, yes - but that's outside of city limits.

What part of NYC lacks elected representation?

NYC is actually within five counties: New York County, Kings County, Bronx County, Queens County, and Richmond County.

It's even more fun/complicated than that.

New York City is dividied into five boroughs, each of which is coterminous with is own county.

Boroughs are subdivivions of New York City City, counties are subdivisions of New York State.

Manhattan is the borough, New York County is the county.

However, I don't think any of the 5 counties that correspond to boroughs have their own governments. So there is no government at all for County of New York, but the Borough of Manhattan does have its own government, which is fine because the County and Borough are coterminous with each other (and both contained entirely within the City of New York).


Both are part of the same NYC local government.

New York City is composed of five boroughs: The Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, and Staten Island. Each borough is coextensive with a respective county of New York State.

NYC is a city made up of 5 counties, whereas Los Angeles County is a county made up of several cities.

Every state does things differently, so I can see the confusion.


NY City has more than half of the congressional districts allotted to NY state, so yes.

New York City is comprised of the five boroughs, not just Manhattan.

each borough is its own county with its own courts, commissioners, sheriff, etc. as far as I understood.

NYPL is a bit of an historical anomaly as far as how it is organized.


Unusually, the county of New York (coextensive with Manhattan) is only 1 of 5 counties inside the city of New York (which of course inside the state of New York).

Ah, didn't know that. I'm a non-NYC dweller and thought it was a separate borough.

Exactly. The 5 boroughs of NYC are really 5 counties anywhere else. And people commute to NYC from NJ and CT sometimes, too.

There are four other boroughs ;-)

Thank you, I was really confused by this because the NYC borough of Brooklyn is actually synonymous with Kings County, and I assumed that OP had merely forgotten the s.

Uh, earth to clueless, New York has plenty of republicans in government. Including the mayor, usually.
next

Legal | privacy