Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Yea, I'm not going to listen to music I want to listen to for the first time on a crowded noisy tube thanks.


sort by: page size:

The price they pay is having me or the conductor telling them to knock it off. Public transport is uncomfortable enough without having to listen to their shitty music selection.

Are you ever annoyed if someone is blasting music you don't like on a train?

Maybe the onus shouldn't be on people to request the music be turned off, but on people not blasting loud music in public nature spaces in the first place?

This is just the kid on the bus/train playing music on his phone speaker. Wear headphones or play the music at a noise/distance that doesn't disturb others.


I'd rather not go at all at that point. Why bother going to a musical performance when you are just going to muffle the sound.

It happens in London too. It's just bad manners to sit and loudly play your poor taste in music out loud on a bus or train rather than on headphones. It's not limited to any particular racial group though; it's usually just young men.

A music lover here. I do not like loud music one bit.

I sometimes listen to music, through headphones, when I'm travelling on my own on a train. Since I regularly make the same journey, it can get a little boring. I'm not always in the mood for work and I don't always carry a book/magazine with me; music is an excellent alternative. I wouldn't dream of playing that music out loud, inflicting it upon everyone else.

That's the boring explanation. It may lack the keen social commentary that the article speculates on, but it happens to be true.


How about just taking me to my floor in silence? I have my own music. Let me choose the experience.

Not if someone else forces you to listen to the music of their choosing. I hate open plan offices and startup kool-aid

well, be thankful you're not hypersensitive to background music. i can't deal with it

Not going to live music, at least in the US.

No one wants to hear your shitty music, get headphones.

STOP THE MUSIC. Please.

I mean, that looks a lot like he hated buskers which is not the same thing. Indeed, it is an attitude I'm extremely sympathetic to. Noisy intrusive music that one cannot avoid is pretty damned unreasonable imo

I actually quite like classical music, but there are times I really don’t want to listen to a solo violin performance. On the way to the subway would almost certainly be one those times. Another such time is tonight, when I immediately had to mute my phone sound when that video started.

There is no way to tell the difference in a subway station, even for an instrument as loud as a violin. Moreover, no one goes to the subway to listen to music.

It's disgraceful to use such a device that deliberately targets the young. I can hear it and it's a annoying as shit and I'm 32. AFAIK they have now been thankfully been banned in the UK/Ireland.

In London, TFL has found the same effect can be hard without some discrimination by playing classical music.


I met someone that doesn't dislike it but is totally indifferent to it. Music for him is like traffic noise.

Were I a member of staff, or even a frequent user who doesn't want his own music, I'd hate having to listen to white noise for extended periods.
next

Legal | privacy