Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Only if he kept it to himself and didn't mention it to anybody - I don't think that's what the OP meant.


sort by: page size:

I think he would have disclosed that if he were unhappy about that, given the already very public nature of the post

He did disclose it.

You wouldn't say that if some private aspect of your own life was revealed to the public without your consent.

Not if you don't tell them about it.

I would think the more important disclosure is if he didn't hold any.

He never said not to tell anyone but he brought up several such details while we were working together. The information wasn’t really helpful for anything in that it wasn’t relevant to our work (making software).

I never revealed the info because it was said in confidence. But we weren’t really that close so it stood out to me.

My example was made up but the actual factoids were about medical issues and bodily functions. It wasn’t creepy or anything just not something I would want widely known.


Or even better, keep it to yourself?

IANAL but:

If you didn't know him and he didn't know you (let's say he got drunk and let it slip when you were driving him in your cab), that's OK for you, not for him.

If you were his wife or his partner in another business or his golf buddy or his therapist, that's generally not OK for you. It also would be illegal for him (I think) since he explicitly told you to trade on the information, but if he just said "things are really busy at work, we're getting a big government grant tomorrow" and there was some expectation you could keep a secret, he might be safe.


What makes you think he would disclose that?

is he not worried about getting in trouble for divulging this?

Honest question: what's the problem if you keep it to yourself ?

it's not, but it is unreasonable to not mention it if you did it.

Yup, you are absolutely right. I'm sorry about that. I usually do disclose it. I just forgot now.

Doesn't disclosing it to a third party count?

No, it was also about who you'd discuss the issue with, even if you knew/suspected that they were disclosed.

As long as he knows, you're OK.

It's not the collecting of data that I was concerned about.

It was the implied secretiveness.


If he doesn't want to be asked about it, he shouldnt tell the public about it.

I wouldn’t use it maliciously, but I would honestly think twice about disclosing it. I think that’s especially true for anyone that doesn’t have a way to gain from the publicity.

No. Mentioning it is only meant to distract.
next

Legal | privacy