Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

> I've never heard any reason to add Vitamin-E to a substance that is already thick.

It's an antioxidant. So it should reduce breakdown of what it's mixed into. And it's fat-soluble.

Since it's a vitamin, it might have been seen as something that's "safe" because it's naturally occurring. But that's easily a myth.



sort by: page size:

It almost sounds too good to be true.

(Just like "enough vitamins", "no fat", "no trans-fat", "no cholesterol", "no carbs", "enough poly-saturated fat", "enough omega 3" seemed to be the solution before)

Anyone with background knowledge can reason for or against the article?


Further, it’s synthetic. I don’t think it exists in any food sources naturally. Probably shouldn’t be in lung tissue:

“vitamin E acetate, is a synthetic form of vitamin E. It is the ester of acetic acid and ?-tocopherol” (Wikipedia)


Soy protein, maltodextrin, and canola oil blended with a multi-vitamin doesn't sound healthy. I suppose it can't be worse than the occasional discount 10-pack of Celese frozen pizza. Paired with a vitamin, of course.

That's what my first thought was when reading about the “miracle ingredient”, and I am confused why no other comments here mention this.

There is a ratio. 5 mg + 0.5 * PUFA. For example, 20g PUFA = 15 mg vitamin E. It gets specific, as more is needed with longer chain PUFAs like DHA.

Lipid peroxidation can also be handled with more vitamin A and 1g+ vitamin C (to recycle the oxidized vitamin A).


Neat experiment. If the cod liver oil's for vitamins, I think cooking will mess that up.

The citric acid and vitamin E in the ingredients list are serving the purpose as preservatives in liquid Dr Bronners.

See also: maple syrup.

And of course EVOO.


It's recommended that iodine/iodide (1,000 mcg+; add 200 mcg L-selenomethionine when taking higher amounts) and vitamin E (2 IU/g) are added when supplementing PUFAs. Iodide/Iodine binds with double bonds making the structure less prone to oxidation and vitamin E counters oxidation.

Most don't get enough vitamin D (and magnesium) even if eating well. 40-60 ng/mL 25(OH)D is a commonly preferred range.


Ah. Yes. I'm familiar with that RVJCM "study." Supplied the raw ingredient you know.

I told them: don't blend this with anything else. My special stuff isn't hamburger helper is it now? Bloody doctors. They should have listened when they had the chance.


>The body needs to convert Omega-3 ALA into DHA or EPA

IIRC it can only convert a few % of it. Hence the love for DHA or EPA supplements.


VitE can be used as an antioxidant/preservative.

VitC is too, but E is fat soluble.


Bear in mind, this is from a year ago, from early in its development. I'm not positive how much of this is inaccurate, but I know that omega-3 and other ingredients were added to round it out. I'd take this article with a grain of salt.

> ps. Body can synthesize omega-3 if there is enough a-linolenic acid (ALA) available.

IIRC, ALA is an Omega 3, just one the human body doesn't use for much. The body can synthesize EPA and DHA (which it does use), but humans are pretty bad at that. It's totally conceivable that the rate of synthesis evolved in the context of regular dietary intake of EPA/DHA, so never needed to provide for all the body's needs.


The active ingredients are not water soluble so you’d need to introduce lipids or something, which sounds pretty gross.

You need to take into account how strong it is before you add great dollops of it to your food. It's great stuff when used wisely.

Interesting read about how consuming essential elements repackaged isn't the same as eating them in their original form: https://www.amazon.com/Ultra-Processed-People-Science-Behind...

It has an interesting quote about fish oil.

> Fish oil doesn't benefit us, but oily fish do.


A nutritionist friend of mine has been doing this for years. At least it doesn't have any negative site effects.

> Other good sources of zinc are nuts, whole grains, legumes, and yeast. [1]

I've found nuts are basically a super food. No need for refrigeration or preservatives/processing to keep edible. I always have bags of shelled organic nuts on hand and eat handfuls on a daily basis. The only down side I've found is cost; nuts, especially organic ones, are more costly than filet mignon per lb at whole foods.

[1] https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/002416.htm

next

Legal | privacy