Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Hope they find making cluster bombs a rewarding career choice.


sort by: page size:

Cluster bombs have such blatant propaganda spread against them by well-meaning but naive individuals. Don't be fooled - look at all their positive uses!

So like cluster munitions then.

Probably less bad than cluster bombs.

Bomb disposal technician?

I knew a guy who was a chemical, nuclear, and biological weapons guy in the army. He took bomb diffusal training, studied old soviet missiles, the lot. What did he do on a day to day basis? Mostly blew up grenades that didn't blow up on their own. Apparently it was super boring.

Only if you ignore what a cluster bomb actually is.

> You could teach how to build a bomb or how to cook meth…

Professionals legally create explosives (military, demolition, mining etc) and literally “cook” meth (the brand name for legal prescription methamphetamine is Desoxyn in the US). These necessary and legitimate jobs require educated individuals.


But people will create bombs, like they don't do now.

They can just hire all of the explosive experts that went through the right channel to develop their skill and knowledge safely.

Cluster munitions are bad, but you have to consider that people often try to hide in houses, in cellars during air raids in the city. Cluster munition will not do much to those people, other than being insanely noisy and terrifying. What will kill those people is a bomb that will drop the house on them.

Indiscriminate killing is a function of decision making process, not the munition itself.


More precise targeting??? With cluster bombs???

I don't know, loitering munitions are pretty much bringing a renaissance to the field of blowing people up.

I designed parts for the cluster-bombs that ultimately were dropped on Libyan beaches and when I saw them "staked" into the ground, my hope was that they'd prove their worth as a deterrent - and that the beaches would remain empty of humans until they had all "gone safe".

What are you making? Nuclear bombs?

With 50 bombs to learn from, I would be amazed if the clever engineers in charge wouldn’t find a way past those measures given enough time and money

Fwiw if I ask a human assistant how to make a bomb I'll probably get a moral lecture too.

Atombombs are worse than cluster bombs so we should use them.

They were trained in how to recognize terrorist tradecraft and bomb-making, not how to make actual bombs.

Yeah, I wanted to be a "nuclear physicist" because I thought explosions were cool, and obviously nuclear explosions were the biggest kind. So obviously a nuclear physicist will be researching how to be able to make even bigger explosions!

Obviously as I grew up, knowing that a) ostensibly the point of being able to make those explosions is to ensure they don't actually happen and b) knowing what we'd use that deterrence power for really took the wind out of my sails. Plus somehow it pays less than software, which I actually had more of a passion for than explosions (though I still respect a good explosion to this day). So yeah. Kids will give pretty arbitrary answers to this question even if they think they do have one.

next

Legal | privacy