Hacker Read
top
|
best
|
new
|
newcomments
|
leaders
|
about
|
bookmarklet
login
eveningcoffee
2020-02-27 18:42:42+00:00
|
next
[–]
update item
(on:
Ask HN: How are you preparing for COVID-19 disruptions?
)
Naturally argumentum ad hominem is always the best strategy.
reply
Loading...
sort by:
oldest
newest
similarity_score
page size:
10
20
50
100
JanneVee | karma 678 | avg karma 3.12
|
2015-10-18 16:23:09
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
Adventures in Twitter Censorship [pdf]
)
You are in essence saying that ad hominem is a valid debating technique.
reply
tut-urut-utut | karma 1261 | avg karma 2.18
|
2024-03-06 21:48:47
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
OpenAI and Elon Musk
)
Ad hominem makes for a damn good argument, especially if the person in case doesn’t try to appease everyone.
reply
GaryTang | karma 106 | avg karma 0.39
|
2021-11-01 09:00:45
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
How War with China Begins
)
Ad hominem attacks are always a great approach to discussions. /s
reply
Mithaldu | karma 8182 | avg karma 2.9
|
2016-10-26 17:58:17+00:00
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
Faster and better browsing – Welcome Opera 41
)
Ah yes, ad hominem, the tool of choice for reasonable people.
reply
gunshai | karma 421 | avg karma 1.72
|
2021-03-21 15:17:17
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
Cryptography behind the top cryptocurrencies
)
Is Ad hominem really the best you can do?
reply
bitshepherd | karma 157 | avg karma 1.64
|
2017-12-02 23:48:57
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
The Great American Single-Family Home Problem
)
Ad hominem is the best way to get the point across. Don't ever change, sir/madam.
reply
xracy | karma 604 | avg karma 1.27
|
2023-10-19 02:58:33
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
Lab leak fight casts chill over virology research
)
Ad hominem attacks are famously the first resort of people who are correct about everything.
reply
greenshackle2 | karma 1836 | avg karma 2.93
|
2019-10-21 14:47:46
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe”
)
Ad hominem is a fair counter-argument to appeal to authority.
reply
darkerside | karma 6585 | avg karma 1.94
|
2017-12-07 18:46:58+00:00
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
The Big Vitamin D Mistake
)
This is what's known as an ad hominem argument
reply
sillysaurus3 | karma 15505 | avg karma 3.87
|
2017-07-30 20:28:26+00:00
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
SoundCloud's Collapse
)
If an ad hominem is the best criticism you can come up with, it seems correct to me.
reply
rhizome | karma 18082 | avg karma 1.64
|
2016-01-06 06:35:37+00:00
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
‘Making a Murderer’ Left Out Crucial Facts, Prosecutor Says
)
Ad hominem doesn't invalidate an argument, it speaks to credibility.
reply
croes | karma 17146 | avg karma 3.11
|
2022-11-27 14:11:33
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
Habits of Highly Overrated People (2013)
)
Ad hominem != arguments
reply
noblethrasher | karma 2878 | avg karma 3.01
|
2014-03-06 10:55:03
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
The Face Behind Bitcoin?
)
Which is precisely why
argumentum ad hominem
is something to be wary of.
reply
hc | karma 95 | avg karma 0.87
|
2009-01-08 05:39:03
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
The Two Flaws Of Libertarian Economics
)
this sort of thing is known as argument ad hominem.
reply
Capira | karma 864 | avg karma 5.4
|
2021-11-21 12:28:58
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
Covid-19: stigmatising the unvaccinated is not justified
)
Argumentum ad hominem usually implies an irrational opinion or manipulative rhetoric.
reply
TimTheTinker | karma 7131 | avg karma 3.4
|
2017-12-02 23:05:51+00:00
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
The Great American Single-Family Home Problem
)
Ad hominem argument, yes.
reply
livestyle | karma 733 | avg karma 2.46
|
2019-02-27 20:37:14+00:00
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page
)
“Ad hominem is a notoriously weak logical argument. And is usually used to distract the focus of a discussion - to move it from an indefensible point and to attack the opponent."
~ Lord Aquitainus Attis
reply
efdee | karma 1745 | avg karma 2.6
|
2014-04-25 12:54:03+00:00
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
TDD isn't dead just because DHH can't do it
)
Ad hominems seldomly make for a constructive argument.
reply
squidlogic | karma 456 | avg karma 3.65
|
2020-09-17 17:58:21
|
next
[–]
similar comments
(on:
We Still Need Howard Zinn
)
Argument ad hominem.
reply
next
Legal
|
privacy
reply