Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Nobody has a single authority on what words mean. That doesn't mean terms don't have established meanings, and it'll make things difficult for you if you insist on using them differently.


sort by: page size:

If you can't understand why words might mean something completely different to anyone who's got a completely different context built around it, you are either ignorant or too arrogant to care either way.

There is no single correct definition for any word. And most people use words to that effect.

It's important to be able to construct specific meanings. You don't need terms to do that, and you run a major communication risk by relying on terms that you aren't willing to define. And if you define them first, then you can use them however you like.

The idea that words used in specific contexts can't have clear meanings is the more tedious thing.

Well you can just redefine the meaning of arbitrary words, but the result is that nobody understands your attempts at communication.

I personally prefer to be effective at communication, so I don't just use words to mean something different than what everyone else thinks.


Hate to break it to you, but words can mean different things than just their dictionary definition.

Merriam-Webster is not the ultimate authority on the English language. If people start using the word to mean something else, then, ipso facto, that's what it means.

If you try to nail it down to a specific definition, you'll wind up in contradictions. English doesn't work like that; when I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean, no more and no less.

There's a massive difference between changing your own word usage to use a term that you think is a better description, and attempting to police other people's word usage.

It obviously doesn't mean what you think it means, because people are using it with a different meaning than what you'd like.

Opinions about the definitions of words can be wrong.

So it's impossible for you to create a new context where those words mean something different?

No. Words have meanings, and that's not one of them.

Words can have multiple meanings. And, some of those meanings can be based on ignorance, bias and sloppiness. It is fair to critique the use of words when they obscure actual meaning.

Appeals to authority is not mysticism.


Your desire to have a word mean something different does not make that alternate meaning correct.

Do you even know the meaning of the words to use ?

Sorry to hammer the point home, but I'm not saying "words can't have different meanings". I'm saying it's not useful to rename "meanings" as "social constructs".

not necessarily; terms are fluid, words mean different things in different contexts.

a) I don't think you get to define words for us all
next

Legal | privacy