Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

We are solving these problems at - https://district.so. Dealing with trolls can be draining and it's a plague for a good community. We working on solving that.

@bredren Would you want to lead /Portland District?



sort by: page size:

What about combatting trolls?

What kind of anti-troll solutions are you considering?

It's the trolly problem.

Trolls are a trivial problem, easily dealt with.

The real problem with practically every internet community is its moderation, because the worst people with the least business doing that job inevitably float to the top and are then impossible to dislodge without voting with your feet and creating an entire new community.


>> I've thought a lot over the last couple years about the problem of trolls. It's an old one, as old as forums, but we're still just learning what the causes are and how to address them.

That's crazy. We still don't know what causes Trolls?


This is awesome! I love these sorts of creative community projects. Have you had to deal with trolls at all and how have you managed that?

This concept is a troll haven. Politically motivated trolls have become a rampant problem online. I think they are the single biggest obstacle to the progress social media (in the broadest definition, which includes this project here) can effect towards non-partisan goals like empathy and factuality. How will you deal with this issue?

if you have a core group which is caring about the health of the community then you might have not this problem. but if the community gets overuned by trolls the admin should take some steps to prevent it. (kick the trolls, close registration temporaly, etc.) (sorry, if my english is broken. i'm a german guy)

It's less a problem of "getting rid" of trolls and more a case of giving people control over them instead of it being such a one-sided deal where trolls get to dictate where, when and how you can socialize.

If people feel like they have tools to push back against trolls they'll use them. If they feel like they're powerless, they'll leave. If they leave the troll to user ratio skews a bit higher and might end up poisoning the entire community.


Concern trolls are civil and can do very great harm to a community.

There is the issue of troll communities on the internet.

People running a campaign to do something or another might not have any other involvement, they could just be in it for the lulz.


Yes. The solution to trolling has always been moderation.

If the moderation is too strict then people leave and setup elsewhere. If it is just the trolls leaving then no one cares and it is a win/win.


If you run online communities it's important to understand troll mentality.

For many of us, it's beyond our thinking.


The article says that kind of thing causes probably with community relations, so I can't blame them for wanting to stop it.

It's just never going to work, though. Trolls will just do it from further away, out of their control.


Fixing the system is hard while harassing a troll is a lot easier. This might lead to avoiding fixing the system altogether -- once people realize how hard it us, both technically and politically, they might stop at beating the troll solution as "good enough for now".

Interesting, but seems like general community management for dealing with newbies rather than actual trolls?

Maybe you could try to do something with the Chinese trolls too? It's becoming a serious problem.

Here's another good explanation of what some of the issues are:

https://www.lightbluetouchpaper.org/2020/04/12/contact-traci...

The problem of trolling seems important to solve.


But what about the trolls?
next

Legal | privacy