Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

I've seen that as well and that only ever happens when the left most lane is also an exiting lane. It's not intuitive by any means but it's also consistent so if you know the rules and can see the road ahead, you'll be safe.


sort by: page size:

Yeah, for whatever reason the right lane very, very frequently turns into an exit with almost no warning.

This is just how the maps are designed. It's only on the rare three lane stretches that you're able to bump over to the middle lane confidently.


That typically means the right lane is turning into an exit lane.

> Here in the US, the right lane very often "disappears", i.e. becomes an "exit only" lane.

Are there any instances where there isn't signage that informs drivers in advance? I'll drive in the right-most lane and if I see one of those signs, I'll check for traffic, signal and move to the lane to my left.


Also in the US they'll use left side exits, which pushes exiting traffic to the "fast" lane. Drives me crazy when road designers do this.

I think this also varies state-to-state, I recently drove from Colorado to Texas and it really seemed to me that in general TX drivers observe the "stay right except to pass" rule much more than CO drivers.


I know that. But what am I supposed to do when the left lane leads to the exit I want to go to?

Also: there was someone in front of me going the same speed, I just left a big gap


Looks like relatively normal behavior for a 7 lane road for either USA or Europe.

Highways with THAT many lanes typically have exits on both the right and left side. People will typically be on whichever side their exit is going to be on.


There cannot be more lane changes into and/or out of the left most lane than the 2nd to left most lane (assuming no left exits) because all lane changes go through it. Furthermore it is fairly easy to get a sense of the best lane by just paying attention.

Yeah, that situation is where I see it 2nd-most; first most is people trying to change lanes into an exit lane right at the exit when they're in a non-exit lane and want to exit. Those are lane changes, though, not merges.

Sometimes it's ambiguous, where you don't know if the exit lane is a new lane or your lane.

In Europe, the lane to your left is in principle always oncoming traffic, unless you see a separate road to your left with a bit of grass in between. Or at least there will be a continuous instead of a dashed line.

I've noticed while driving in the US that American highway exits seem to be designed differently than those in the UK. The rightmost lane of three-lane highways will often become the exit lane, so if you stick to the rightmost lane you'll frequently need to switch lanes to your left to stay on the road. In the UK, in contrast, the exit lane is usually the new lane, and you have to switch lanes to get into it.

So instead of constant lane switching, use the middle lane for going straight ahead, and the leftmost lane for passing.


Easy to say, but that's not true in all places. Here's one where the left 2 lanes are left turn lanes, and the leftmost left turn lane turns into the 2nd from left lane.

Big potential for accident for the right left turn lane to accidentally also turn into the same (2nd from left) lane and crash.

And NO, they don't know a priori that the leftmost lane of the street they are turning into is a left turn lane.

https://www.google.com/maps/@37.3626182,-121.8918193,3a,75y,...

They should seriously hang a HUGE sign like this and make it abundantly clear:

https://imgur.com/a/BLoor05


Just watch out for left-hand exits like the HOV lanes at the Hwy 85 split going southbound.

Let's start "Falsehoods self-driving programmers believe about roads:"

All highway exits are to the right from the right-hand lane. If the left lane line curves away, the road is curving and you should follow it.


I stand corrected!

Maybe I'm remembering the rules of left turns? As long as there was only one left turning lane (and you had the left turn arrow), you could turn into any of the new lanes (not just the left most lane).

Combine that with people who turn right into other-than-the-right-most-lane, and you've got a recipe for disaster.


It seems pretty consistent in the other videos they're showing, too. The left-hand lane marking splits into two lines ahead of the gore point. If the further of those two lines from the car is significantly stronger than the other, then the car will choose that as its new 'left lane' (rather than always choosing the nearer one) and follow it straight into the gore point. I don't think this is a mysterious bug, so much as a significant corner case where their system fails.

+there are times when you are not blocked by oncoming traffic, so I guess it's OK to turn left there. And many other cases like that...

And I doubt this is a global rule.


I have noticed this as well. Much easier too when it's saying which lane to be in when you're exiting a highway

As others have stated, the left most lane is most certainly not always the "passing" lane. Which, for some people, the "passing" lane means "drive as fast as I want get out of my way" lane.

Maybe I didn't make it clear, people will be in the right lane and the assistant will instruct them last second to move to the left lane. This creates a dangerous situations as many US drivers do not care about traffic laws and cross the median. This is dangerous since this is generally unexpected to other drivers who will often have to sverve / brake to avoid collissions.
next

Legal | privacy