Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

In some countries, a surprise raid of your home means “we think you have hostages in your basement” or something at that level.


sort by: page size:

I know, it was a joke :)

I've actually had my home raided before... not fun. Fortunately I no longer live in America.


Then don't be surprised if they storm your house and take your stuff.

It's insane.

He literally said 'there's something behind this door, we don't know whether it's a guy with a rocket launcher or an innocent baby, so let's throw a grenade in there and 'gain the initiative' whichever case it may be'.

I never quite understood raids in the first place. Between scoping out a house, arresting any individuals outside as they walk on the curb while entering an empty home with a warrant, and raiding a house delta-force style with guns, an unknown number of people in the house with no knowledge of what you'll find. I'm sure house raids have their place, but to me that place feels rather limited. Raiding someone's house because of something like pot, or selling nachos, with grenades and all?


How is knocking on someone's door an "incursion" or a "surprise attack"?

You seem to have left out an important detail, why did your house get raided by the police?

Yeah, is this just an urban legend? Fake videos, etc.? It's always seemed absurd to me that you can send men with guns to raid someone's house just with an anonymous phone call.

This definitely sounds like some agency was using/used the home as a safe house.

So they can break into your house because it happens all the time.

Why would someone get raided?

I wish I knew why they couldn't just send 2 officers to knock on the door and ask, if the home owner refused then bring in a task force. US Police get more money when they send in a force than just one or two officers.

That was a semi-raid, because they didn't break down his door and force him to the ground while ransacking his house.

Still a raid yes.


Well they might do other things in to your house, now they have the keys.

That could apply if they were raiding the house of some violent gang member, not a scientist from which they only wanted some electronics.

An armed raid on a specific person's house house isn't random, however raiding any house in a particular neighbourhood would fulfil such a definition.

That's all true. But you clearly indicated "kidnapping you out of your home", and I suspect there are indeed panic rooms you can buy that will prevent that (even if they clearly cannot prevent the above scenarios).

Is an armed raid on someone's house not random violence?

My point is just, local attacker, "the call is coming inside the house!". You have big problems at this point.

Wouldn't it be reasonable to observe the house for a while before a raid? That's where you pick up on clues as to who lives there. "Hmmm, seems to be a lot of small children here and not too many gang style criminals. Ok, team, we go in fast, but force probably won't be necessary." Oh, wait. This type of thinking would probably prevent the no-knock raid to begin with.

There's also the possibility of swatting[1]. There are videos online of people streaming when suddenly their home is broken into by officers, rifle in hand, yelling at them to get on the ground.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting


How do they know it's you in the house? What if you took somebody there? What if somebody else is using your house?

Seems like just the thing to do before I drag someone into my basement. "Hey officers, my house is off limits, cya"

next

Legal | privacy