Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

I agree that this is an issue, but I don't think that's anywhere near what Bitcoin uses.


sort by: page size:

True, but that's a uniquely Bitcoin problem, and it's one of the many reasons Bitcoin is not fit for purpose.

No true Bitcoin has this problem, of course.

Hmm, with bitcoin, how is this a problem?

I agree but am not sure whether this is a fundamental problem or merely a current one, with bitcoin.

Is it necessarily cumbersome or just happens to be like that at the moment?

My intuitive feeling is that it can't be inherently cumbersome; that _must_ be an addressable problem.


That's mostly a Bitcoin-only issue, luckily.

Oh, so your point is that bitcoin-specific problems aren't a problem outside of Bitcoin. Gotcha.

That's a problem that hasn't been solved (yet).

That shouldn't diminish all the other things that BTC does successfully.


I agree with the premise that Bitcoin is too hard to use for all but the most technically minded people.

I hadn't really considered that; I was only vaguely aware it was possible. Yes, that's a problem.

I'm inclined to think of Bitcoin as the beta for widespread adoption of cryptocurrency. It has some issues, including this one that mean it will probably never be what most people use for everyday money. Whatever succeeds it and eventually assumes that role will avoid those problems.


I don't think there is a problem with the way bitcoin works. The majority of miners, i.e. the people who actually have invested the money to run the network, decide what software to run, and therefore what bitcoin is.

Bitcoin depends entirely on the self-interest of the involved parties to not destroy the system they have invested so much in. That's how much of the real world works too.


Well, then that's a flaw in Bitcoin.

Well, I'm not saying bitcoin is perfect or fit for mainstream usage for that matter, but for what is worth, that is bound to happen with anything digital. Security data breaches are a recurring problem for internet companies and services too.

This could pose a problem to the BitCoin money supply.

I don't see it as a significant problem. Those hurdles only need to be crossed for folks using Bitcoin to do so safely. If they are not crossed, it's only Bitcoin users that are harmed. Since there is nothing to force anyone to use it, all possible harm arising from weaknesses in the underlying infrastructure is opt-in.

Come on, Monero for example doesn't do this, so your argument might stand against Bitcoin specific, but not against cryptocurrency in general.

I'm not sure what you're getting at? This isn't something that'd happen with bitcoin either.

To be fair Bitcoin is also having trouble with this

Yes, that is the primary concern. "We" in the bitcoin community haven't yet figured out how to write 100% correct alternative implementations of bitcoin. We will have to figure out how to do that first before I would ever recommend anybody actually run an alternative implementation as a full node and rely on it for seeing the blockchain.

You can't really point to a particular Bitcoin and say, "That's my Bitcoin."
next

Legal | privacy