Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Are you sure you want to say that people who like comic books are hedonists? That’s an overly cut and dried argument and people aren’t nearly that simple. Isn’t it more charitable and accurate to suggest that people like what they like? I like running obscenely long distances. First, what business is it of yours how others spend their time? Second, what possibly qualifies you to claim people are hedonists because they like what they like??

There’s nothing wrong with recreation or having fun. Life is very short and no matter how hard you work or how much you learn, you’re going to die.

Live your life. Don’t let others call you names for being you. The converse is that when you don’t understand how others live, don’t call them hedonists. You just don’t understand because you’re you, not them.



sort by: page size:

Or maybe just read more about hedonism? By your definition, you’re a hedonist as well because intellectual pleasure is still pleasure.

Instead, I argue that that is a loaded term, we’re all individuals and we like what we like. It’s really nobody’s business and certainly nobody’s place to add a term (especially one with such negative pop connotations) to people who like what they like.


I've said it before and I'll say it again, hedonism gets a bad rap.

What's wrong with hedonism? Or am I misreading what you're saying.

I don't think you meant it, but the way you put that makes it sound like you don't think people should ever indulge in things they enjoy.

I think you are missing the point. People do stuff because they enjoy doing it. The fact that they enjoy doing stuff you don't is their business, and frankly it would be a boring world if we all liked the same things.

Lower-case hedonism (not the philosophy) gets a deservedly bad rap. There is little long-term satisfaction in pleasure-seeking.

Maybe Hedonism is sound.


What's with the incessant need to tell other people how to enjoy an experience?

I'm reminded of this xkcd comic: https://xkcd.com/1314/


I think that’s an incorrect assumption. People are often bad at articulating why they enjoy something.

Like I said: Who are you to say how people should enjoy themselves?

Are you seriously telling someone else how they should enjoy something?

Who are you to criticise someone else’s choices and what they enjoy? You do what you enjoy. Let them do what they enjoy.

Your implication is that you don't want to enjoy anything because you might turn into a snob... Some sort of meta-snobbish anti-hedonistic hero?

If you need to judge people for what they enjoy to have a joyful life I’m sorry for you.

I think this is a good way to demonize a person for displaying proud ignorance of a topic but is probably inaccurate. Just as I simply do not care about celebrity news (rather than actively despise its existence), I’m sure many people simply do not care about many of the things I enjoy. I don’t begrudge them that. We all have a limited time on earth, and we spend that time on things we enjoy. Most of us probably can’t even explain _why_ we like the things we do, but part of enjoying what we do means not over analyzing it, and rather just giving ourselves to it. I think this applies universally to interests.

Don't be derisive of things that other people enjoy.

Not trying to offend, but . . .

> If I enjoy xyz, who are you to judge me for that?

I find this (common) sentiment troubling and frankly a bit arrogant.

Whether or not you enjoy something is not always good metric for said thing's long term effects on your life.

Other people have experienced different things than you and may have some really good insights. Assuming you know exactly what's best strikes me as arrogant. Judgement and ostracization, while often misused, are effective tools for a society to encourage beneficial behaviours.


The strong claim is that I, and most people, actually enjoy what we say we enjoy? That is dangerous levels of cynicism.

I was referring to the general complaint of the parent poster about how people feel enjoying pleasures is wrong.

You don't have to enjoy it for it to be good to someone
next

Legal | privacy