Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Stalin was worse


sort by: page size:

stalin was worse than hitler. caused much more death and misery.

Hitler was horrible. Stalin was horrible. Stalin killed more people. But Stalin had more years in which to do it, and ruled a larger population. If you calculate (total body count) / (people-years ruled), I suspect Hitler was worse. (He might not be worse than Pol Pot, though...)

It is even less appropriate in the light of the fact that Stalin was one of the most brutally incompetent tyrants ever.

Isn't this the "Stalin was just as bad as Hitler" argument?

??????

There's a long and terrible tradition of western media regarding Stalin as literally worse than Hitler.


Hitler or Stalin?

Stalin

Uh, Stalin is responsible for more suffering than possibly anyone in recent history. He probably killed more russian people than the german soldiers.

His policies screwed up a significant part of the world for decades.


Maybe Stalin.

He was working for Stalin. The man is on a very short list for worst person of the entire 20th century, and it's a tough competition! The "criminal elements" are pikers in comparison.

Josef Stalin? Yep.

Would you rather it was Stalin?

Well, yeah. Stalin was a monster. He was just good at being a monster.

You comparing Stalin to Hitler? Are people mad these days?

Nobody is suggesting that Stalin was not one of the worst totalitarian tyrants ever. He is personally responsible for more deaths than anyone else, and possibly even Hitler.

And yet, somehow, the US manages to lock more people in prison than this totalitarian scumbag. That should be food for thought for anyone with half a brain.


Stalin's propaganda was even effective in the U.S. He really deserves to be at the top of the list when evil leaders are discussed. Yes, Hitler was awful, but Stalin was far worse. But saying so often draws only criticism. That's how good his propaganda was.

I would leave out the comparison of the evils, but it is true that many forget Stalin (and others by the way; Pol Pot for instance) while Hilter is known by all as ‘most evil human’.

Yep, and they're literally worse than Stalin in this regard.

At least he had an appreciation for statistics, and accurate body counts.


this is simply not true, please read up on Holodomor, forced Chechen relocation, etc. Stalin was pretty much as evil as Hitler.
next

Legal | privacy