Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Meaning it's more acceptable to not comply with cultural standards: i.e. keep standard hours, have a job, not marry/have kids, or whatever else the standards of behavior are.

I'm not convinced though that developing countries are actually lower compliance but that's what the OP means.



sort by: page size:

> Those countries are more demographically/culturally uniform and are higher trust societies

What does that even mean?


Well, I’m in Europe, the situation is better here. It certainly is a matter of cultural norms.

Same lessons from India, so I think it's a developing world thing. Or maybe even a high-income-disparity-culture thing?

Cultures of course vary in the particular norms they enforce. Many East Asian countries don’t have strong social norms in favor of procreation despite otherwise being strongly norm oriented. But of course a society that isn’t strongly norm oriented loses the ability to enforce that norm as well as other socially desirable behaviors.

COVID is another example. The breakdown of norm-oriented behavior has been especially acute where the counter-culture of the 1970s collided with deindustrialization. The fallout was mitigated in certain blue areas by high levels of education. But I’m much of the country it ended up destroying the framework of norms that helped mediocre and not especially educated people make good decisions.


Different culture, less glorification of the individual.

Sure. I'm just pointing out that different cultures have very different expectations / priorities. :)

Different countries have different cultural norms and laws.

I'm curious if you or anyone else can share more detail or some examples regarding cross-cultural differences in societal expectations.

I've got some guesses about what this might mean, but I haven't studied this, and don't have any personal experience here.


I don't know about that. In my experience, with smaller places I'm familiar with, the cultural input only enriches, there's no degradation (though I am of course aware of certain areas of certain countries where they failed to handle immigration correctly and created isolated ghettos - that never goes well. But it does not have to be that way).

"sophisticated set of shared rules and norms" - I don't know what that's supposed to mean. I definitely get a bad feeling from a sentence like that though.


Different societies have different social standards. This is assuming you are none British/English/etc.

Where in Africa, Asia, the Middle East, etc do they not value family highly? It's the traditional culture in most countries

> far fewer cultural problems

Do most people in those countries look the same?


> The original article is mainly about US and Canada, where it's much less typical

That's extremely variable over time, and it's been very much in the rise in recent decades, IIRC.

Of course, it may be a matter where cultural attitudes toward behavior are much stickier than actual behavior.


It's just a different culture. Societal harmony is more important then individuality.

A very Asian mentality, this (I'm living in SE Asia). Conformity and obedience are strongly-held cultural values.

Well, you don't get to define what's "worse-off" for another culture. And should that give us pause about current policies that may cause the same behaviour later on?

The thing is that all behaviours carry cultural aspects to them. But clearly some behaviours lead to better economic outcomes than others right? Being sober, working hard, valuing education, cooperating well, these are cultural traits. This fact alone doesn't mean it's wrong to prefer them.

Don't be so quick to judge the issues of developing country's societies through the lens of western cultures. What appears similar at surface level, might have completely different root causes and effects. The other replies here have added some interesting points.

I know where you're going with that but some cultures really are better in some ways. I don't think cultures that overly promote conformity and are "strong" for example. Nor are ones that tolerate too much corruption or dysfunctional behavior. Neither are ones that have no sense of self-preservation and allow infinite outside influence.
next

Legal | privacy