Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

I would think the today's code is not a part of the Copilot yet...


sort by: page size:

Yeah, I don't find I end up with copilot code that survives very long as it came.

And copilot-like code, possibly Q1 2023.

Please no. If you can’t understand the code, how can you possibly verify that what copilot or similar has produced is correct?

Copilot NEEDs to be trained on licensed code,so that it doesn't produce them

I was hoping that including profanity would prevent code from being hoovered up by Copilot, but that doesn't appear to be the case. That's too bad.

In case anyone interprets this literally: if copilot regurgitates literal code it was trained on that doesn't actually give you an unencumbered version.

I don't know anything about Copilot's design, but surely they passed all the code they fed it in the training stage through some pretty strict linters, right? I mean that's just common sense...

They don't give any source or anything; the way it's worded sounds ambiguous enough that I suspect it's not that 50% of their code is generated by Copilot. Is there something a bit more convincing elsewhere?

If that were true, Copilot would have been scanning windows and office source code. But we don't see that.

If that code managed to hit production, then the problem is with the management and engineering leadership, not Copilot.

I can say with a certain degree of confidence that you haven't actually used CoPilot daily.

> How comes, that Copilot hasn't indicated, where the code came from?

I can't say for sure about copilot but in general you don't have that kind of information. The problem is a bit like trying to add debug symbols back to some highly optimized binary program.


yeah, and with copilot more less tested code will be produced.

> I don't use CoPilot. If that's the #1 complaint the rest is peanuts.

CoPilot launders your code, it doesn't matter whether you use it or not.


There is no way 33% of code is written with Copilot. I want to see the data backing that claim up.

What does this have to do with Copilot?

I'm more concerned with all the poor code and security issues that Copilot has been trained on. Garbage In, Garbage Out.

it specifically says Copilot

half of co-pilot users' code, not half of all users' code.
next

Legal | privacy