Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Trains may not be available.


sort by: page size:

You mean on days other than those days when no trains run whatsoever?[1]

[1] Due to failure in the IT system, it is not possible to run any trains today (ns.nl)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30901009


Seconded. Clicking on numerous train lines/stations simply state there are no available trains for almost the entire week.

Trains won't do last mile delivery.

Some commuter rail lines in the U.S. are designed to only cater to commuters. So they may not run any train into downtown at night, or they may stop running well before the shows end at night, so there's no way to use the trains to get back home.

Well, the rail line is behind schedule.

Trains are really slow actually.

In Japan they might be a little delayed. In Boston the trains just don't come at all. One time I was stuck on a train for four hours because a switch was frozen (normally a 40 minute trip).

My bad, didn't realise there were so many stations shut down.

I travelled without any hassles on those days so I assumed just a couple of main stations were closed.


I don't understand how a train may not be on schedule. There's two rails on which the train runs in completely deterministic matter, unlike air or car traffic.

This implies that rail is running at capacity during the night, which I suspect isn’t true.

It’s not a choice between 1 car-train or 1 normal night train - you can have both if there is line capacity.

And you probably aren’t running sleeper carriages during peak hours.


A station becoming unexpectedly busy may have knock-on effects (e.g. taking longer to make your way through and thus missing a train), so it might not be a net benefit.

I seem to remember from the original publication that the train would break down if it spent 10 days idle in some spot, away from a station.

I guess the logic being that it could be an unknown service location.


You can only see the trains around sunset and that only a while after launch.

There are very few nighttime trains and it would take me a good extra hour to get home even once I caught one of the sparse trains. If I had to take the train in for a play I'd simply pass.

Right, the train station. If there isn't another train on 30 minutes or less you don't have enough riders to pay for trains in the first place

Propably because the platform is not yet free or they can't yet get a route to the platform (because some other trains need to pass through first)?

Chicago is the exception here, though. It's the core hub of the entire system, and there are no trains that pass through Chicago. A Chicago train will nearly always leave on-time, unless there are equipment issues.

1. Such train may not exist. 2. Train at more convenient time could be fully booked. 3. Train at more convenient time could be significantly more expensive.

The issue isn’t who runs it, it’s that the trains don’t have tracks to reasonably run on. Elsewhere, when passenger trains are delayed, every effort is made to get them back on time again - in America, they’re left for hours in a siding while freight trains go by.
next

Legal | privacy