Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Is it just me or is this such a stereotypical American comment?


sort by: page size:

This is such an American comment.

This is such an American comment to make

This remark is incredibly American.

No, I’m American and found it one of the funniest comments I’ve read in a while.

> stereotypically "conservative in tastes" white america

I've never seen this stereotype before. You sure you aren't talking about brits?


amusing that a comment designed to mock the irrationality and simple-mindedness of "Americans", itself provides a strong example of overgeneralizing entire populations, society and culture into simple, easy-to-understand tropes suitable for simpletons.

Yes, I realised I was over generalising as soon as I made that comment - I was mostly (over)reacting to the parent comment that did imply that it was a part of American culture.

This is an unreasonable comment even for an American. But in other countries it's especially not a concern. You might have to report it to a different government agency (like an archaeologist or animal control) but you are supposed to report it to someone.

The other reddit category of things you should report to the police (or someone else) is of course people who find old grenades in their house.

https://www.reddit.com/r/whatisthisthing/comments/4x9u4p/unc...


Is this a joke comment? Or is this really what the average American thinks?

Is this genuinely something that someone would say in America, or are you just making a tongue-in-cheek remark?

The fun thing about comments like that is that as a non American, I'm often not entirely sure which side of their bafflingly bullshit culture wars the comments are coming from.

Maybe I read too much reddit and I've been primed [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Priming_(psychology)]

But I read this as another anti-American comment which seems to be very fashionable recently.


There is nothing intrinsically american about this statement. If you think it is black and white, then fine, argue that point. By adding the phrase "In typical american fashion" you transform your post from a potentially valid point into a pointless petulant insult.

That's quite possibly the most American response you could provide.

Neither the Author is American, nor am I. Sometimes it seems, though, racial stereotypes are perfectly acceptable...


Do you actually think that this comment adds to the conversation at hand or are you just using this as an opportunity to wedge in the 'but America does it too!' trope?

First word of his comment gives it away, 'Generalizations' rather than 'Generalisations' make it obvious he's American.

Wait... Did you not read the comment? It's talking about American culture...

As an American, I'm extremely curious. What does your nationality have to do with that comment?

I'm American in this is one of the most sensible comments I've read so far.
next

Legal | privacy