Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Maybe an alcohol test in the car. If too drunk it wont start and call an uber


sort by: page size:

We'd need a dashboard indicator to indicate that it refused to start due to alcohol. After all, it might just be broken down independent of the driver's alcoholic state at that point.

While we are at it, how about equipping all cars with a breathalyzer so if you have above normal alcohol levels the car won’t start?

Also, more importantly, you have to verify that the user is not at the moment incapable of operating a vehicle, i.e drunk.

What if the vehicle is really drunk?

I'd rather just replace the ignition system with a short driving game that you have to complete to start the car

I've heard there are cars with a breath analyzer connected to the ignition. A driving game would hopefully pick up more than alcohol, so I like that idea. Unfortunately, I suspect many drunk drivers will just do what they do with the current systems and have their sober girlfriend pass the test for them.


This. Why shouldn't driver assist be able to tell when the actual driver is drunk/tired/dangerously incompetent and pull over. It could even call their emergency contact or a taxi and disable the car.

Would that or mandatory breathalyser to start the car do more?

Mandatory alcohol testing when you start up the engine would be a good start.

Also, what if I'm the designated driver and I'm taking 3 of my drunk friends home. How likely would this system be to give a false positive and now the responsible person's car won't start until you get a bunch of drunks out of the car and air it out.

Or carpool and have the driver not drink

I think random breath testing by police is a better idea.

Your car stopping you from drink driving will false positive too much or just break. Drinkers will just buy older cars anyway. Let’s keep cars simple!


have their sober girlfriend pass the test for them.

Good point. It needs some form of seat sensor that turns the engine back off if the person in the driving seat changes.


The machine knows better than drunk-you, sure. The concern is when the machine doesn't let sober-you drive because it incorrectly thinks you're drunk.

Hmm. How will they check for alcohol? Would you still be able to drive home a car full of drunks while sober? Only with all windows open?

You can be too drunk to drive without being visibly intoxicated.

Regardless the impetus is on the individual to take an Uber to the bar if they plan on drinking.


That option was tried: a company developed a safety system on top of a car’s ignition. To start, the driver had to blow into an alcohol test. It was meant for parents’ letting their teenagers drive their car and court-mandates.

The system was rapidly scraped when people realise someone else could easily blow in.


The problem is not drunk drivers but incapacitated drivers, whether due to alcohol, drugs, lack of sleep, distractions (mobile phones), etc.

The fix is not arbitrary alcohol blood levels, or extending the "War on Drugs", but with standardized, enforced, in-vehicle continuous testing that ensures that the driver is awake, responsive, and in control of the vehicle.

That is something where R&D in AI/ML/software to analyze and detect incapacity could/should be directed.

It can be entirely on/in-vehicle, with access to the data only available to law enforcement (and, perhaps, insurance companies), if and when it is needed to determine liability (not as a general "carte blanche" for the data), in the same way that aircraft black boxes are only analyzed for investigation after an incident.


Really good way to prevent drunk driving: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignition_interlock_device

I've also seen breathalyzers in some bars where you can check your BAC before going anywhere.


Services like Uber protects the road from drunk drivers. We want it to be easy to use while drunk.
next

Legal | privacy