Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

You've clearly never had the displeasure of filing a Radar report.

It's about as effective to write the report on paper and light it on fire - the chance of it getting actually addressed is about the same.



sort by: page size:

Submitting Radar reports now is a complete waste of time, they go straight to the trash. Maybe if you're a recognizable name you'd get an engineer involved, but I doubt it.

File a Radar.

File a radar.

If you care enough, I suggest filing a radar.

I can assure you, radars have 8 more chance of getting something changed verses just compaining about it on a website.

File the radars.


Have you filed a radar bug?

How so? Radar reports don't garner any payouts, do you mean with other companies?

Out of curiosity, have you filed a Radar bug?

> this is the type of thing that’ll get fixed immediately if you file a Radar on it

This isn't how Radar works :(


"when the radar goes red, I'd kill to have a report of what was running there"

I agree. As it stands right now I don't see a use for it.


Apparently filed a Radar report on Jan 15, 2015.

I agree. Unfortunately military radars are classified systems, and civil radars do not currently publish any such information systematically either. So we are left with anecdotes.

If people started demanding such data to be collected systematically and published, then it could be researched. But for the most part the stigma around the subject makes people not bother asking for these sort of things.


If Radar did even a tiny bit of what it's advertised to do, it seems like this shouldn't have happened.

Just to be clear, that claim about the radar doesn't even true.

Why avoid radar data?

I look at it from the opposite perspective.

If you were a foreign power running things in military ranges that gave odd sensor readings (say, balloons with radar characterization gear), wouldn't it be convenient if your adversary dismissed reports as fanciful?

The fact is that any contact in a military range, where militarily valuable radar and signal emissions abound, is a threat to national security.

Gear is going to malfunction and throw off a non-zero number of false positives. But any contact is important enough that it at least deserves to have a report taken and logged on it.


TL:DR; Radar is not the silver bullet here

I've filed a Radar^H^H^H^HFeedback...

This particular issue is not really worthy of being reported in the media. Yes, there are radar problems that require it to be rebooted. But the issues have been identified and a fix is in work and will be rolled out soon. This story is a non-starter.
next

Legal | privacy