Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

It funny, today I also learned that Singapore and Hong Kong were one of the few countries that ignored DMCA. (I kind of expected Uzbekistan to be on the list !)


sort by: page size:

What countries are there that do not honor the DMCA? That would be a good place to host these types of software.

Don't some countries treat the US DMCA similarly?

Thankfully the DMCA only applies to one country and not all the other ones..

In which countries could you host, where the DMCA isn't applicable or enforced?

I don't know anything about how frequently Eastern European and Middle East countries act on DMCA. But I do know that this frequently occurs with US ISPs.

So anyone outside of US should ignore DMCA I believe? Just an example.

DMCA only works in the United States.

DMCA is not a worldwide law.

I thought DMCA was a US thing?

The only two places I know that haven’t criminalised the circumvention of technical protection measures are Israel and Afghanistan. I’d love to be told different.

(I feel there’s still an opportunity to challenge DMCA 1201 in the US, and then there’s also the triennial review. It’s harder in places where the exemptions are hard-coded — but maybe you know of one that includes an exemption for this kind of DRM removal?).


DMCA has no reach outside of USA.

DMCA itself is obviously an US law, but many Western countries have similar laws.

I wish some people from non-western countries would step up and file more fraudulent DMCA notices. Preferably from Russia or China, where they are out of reach for a western court. The current DMCA system needs to learn some defenses against misuse.

The DMCA is toothless in China.

You do know that US law is imposed everywhere in the world, right? DMCA notices and stuff like that.

America ? World. The DMCA does not apply outside of America.

For example, if you host this list in Russia DMCA will not do anything because (sorry for my French) Russia does not give a shit about U.S. copyright laws.

Only in America. The rest of the world doesn't have the DMCA.

Only in countries with laws similar to the DMCA is it illegal.
next

Legal | privacy