Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Some are. I don't think allulose and erythritol ever made me crap.


sort by: page size:

> Importantly, as HN folks seem to like supplements, you should be aware that most fiber supplements and additives are insoluble fiber

This is untrue, most supplements are soluble fiber.


Contradiction: your fiber supplement is also probably a highly processed food.

sorbitol is a laxative, pretty sure taking a laxative every single day is not great for you

All of that insoluble (as opposed to soluble) fiber is not the best, either.

Yes, but in my creatine blend I also have psyllium powder. It acts as a laxative since raw flour can is a good way to get constipated.

They're not entirely bad though, like candy for instance, though perhaps they should be treated like candy. There appears to be some evidence that fibre suppresses the insulin response required to turn sugar to fat.

Is it the added fiber?

I'm more curious about Allulose[1] which is claimed to have anti-hyperglycemic effects by reducing glucose absorption in the intestines.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psicose

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32708827/


Honestly, maybe you aren't getting enough fiber. I take a psyllium husk pill a few times a week. If I take one daily I could literally get away with zero wipes some days if I wanted...

Yep, the best selling fiber supplements on Amazon right now are made of wheat dextrose, polydextrose, and psyllium husk, all of which are forms of soluble fiber.

Not to mention the constipation. Different fiber affects people differently I suppose, but for me, flax seed binds me up pretty bad.

'natural' usually comes with fiber, which makes it's digestion completely different.

I wonder if that's something I should do. I noticed once or twice if I ate something with pumpkin puree in it, the next day my bowels were heavenly.

Do you have a different reaction to soluble vs insoluble fiber?


I'm no true dietician, but curious: do you have issues normally with other fiber laden foods?

But they have a lot of fiber which is supposed to be the antidote for sweet.

This seems fundamentally the same as insoluble fiber component of plants/vegetables. Why not just eat a bunch of cellulose/lignin/chitin/other non-starch polysaccharides, seems less likely to have some bad/unexpected side-effect.

I didn't make that comment, and I can't immediately provide proof of the health of a regular diet vs a bunch of supplements.

But they have a ton of sodium and not much fiber, so if anything you'd get pretty constipated.


The article implied the fiber led to digestion issues.

There is little evidence of that.

But there is a ton of evidence that eating more fibers does help. And this should be favored before any random supplement of more often that not dubious quality.

next

Legal | privacy