Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Roth IRAs have contribution limits.


sort by: page size:

There is a $6000 contribution limit to a Roth IRA already.

One issue with the Roth IRA. You're contribution limit goes to zero after you make more than around 180K (depending on how you file).

Aren't the contribution limits on IRAs only referring to the tax deductible portion? I thought you could contribute after-tax dollars without a limit.

You can do a backdoor Roth IRA contribution. It has no limits.

They'd need to raise the limits then - the contribution limits on traditional/Roth IRAs are significantly lower than employer plans like 401ks.

Put money into your Roth IRA regardless of the market. Your annual contribution limit is likely to be $5,500 like most folks. Keep it in cash if you're worried. Just consider: if you max out your contributions over the next 40 years of your life, the most you can ever contribute to your Roth IRA is about $220,000. That's it.

FWIW, IRA contribution limits are $5500/yr. You can't put $100k in an IRA all at once.

You can't really max out a Roth IRA (that's an illusion). Backdoor contributions are unlimited.

Good advice. Worth noting that IRAs have income caps for contributions.

https://www.rothira.com/roth-ira-limits


Roth IRA restricts contribution based on income. Furthermore, the contribution limits are a small fraction of what they are for employer-based retirement accounts, not enough to build a real retirement.

A not small number of high-income Americans don’t qualify for anything but a traditional IRA, which has paltry limits.


Those can wind up deferring taxes, not eliminating them, and still they have exemption limits. The Roth IRA has contribution limits.

Only Roth IRA is limited to $5k a year.

I was a bit miffed to learn that the max contribution for an IRA and Roth IRA combined is only $5,500. I did some reading and understand the point of it but I would much prefer to be in control of my own money and where it is invested than some of the limited options given through an employer's 401k.

This is how I feel about the income limits for Roth IRA contributions as well.

You have to have contributed as much to a traditional IRA, which still has contribution limits.

I didn't realize my Roth IRA contributions limits are curtailed starting at ~$125k income.

My income is around that, although I guess I wouldn't hit the limit due to maxing my 401K.

What would happen if I contributed too much to an IRA one year? Would I have to pay a penalty during tax season? Would I get the difference back in cash?


If it isn't only a rich people thing, then how do people amass hundreds of millions and even billions in Roth IRA accounts? Those numbers far exceed, by many orders of magnitude, the contribution limits and assumptions of 10% growth over decades.

That's a tax deduction limit not an IRA contribution limit. You make an after-tax IRA contribution (up to the IRA contribution limit of $6K/year in 2019) not subject to any income limit and then convert to Roth IRA.

right, but then how did he convert them to roth? roth has contribution limits, right? Ah, there are no limits for backdoor conversion.
next

Legal | privacy