Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

They aren't some poor dev struggling to eat and pay bills, they've been one of the most popular third party Twitter apps for 15 years. They are not down.


sort by: page size:

Sure, build your app with dependency on software from Twitter, because looking back their relationship to developers has been so great until now, and surely they won't abandon this project after two years...

> Is this the end for Twitter 3rd party developers?

Uh, no.


It doesn't kill of 3rd party Apps, it just requires them to do a minimum amount of monetisation.

The pricing is actually reasonable. 1/4the of Twitters price.


For Twitter third party clients are basically competition so it's not surprising that they make API access as limited as possible. Furthermore because of network effects they are not afraid that a significant number of people will leave the platform.

The APIs for Twitter that they're cutting off aren't being cut off for other uses, though. This clearly isn't a maintenance issue.

That's pathetic... it's such a shame Twitter intentionally crippled their API because the platform is so well suited for 3rd party apps

Currently it looks like 3rd party apps have been cut off, not the Twitter or the API being down. So I don't consider it out of place.

The piece did not say "third party". I'm assuming these clients are the official Twitter mobile apps.

You apparently don't remember 10 years ago when Twitter was killing all the most popular third party twitter clients with its stingy token limit

https://www.androidpolice.com/2013/02/23/falcon-pro-hits-100...

I haven't used third party clients on Twitter for about a decade because the API was so limited nobody could make a fully-featured app.


You don't have an app if you build around the twitter API. Twitter has another app that you maintain. It's not YOUR business, it's theirs, and they can hold it for ransom anytime they want.

Did you miss when Twitter explicitly told developers not to make any more third-party Twitter clients? The situation is simple, and just as the comment you replied to states.

Twitter official app learned a lot about these 3rd party clients, also they didn't think their default experience should be alienating to most users

If I didn’t have a good third party client (no ads, no sponsored tweets, all chronoligical) I would have left Twitter long ago. I don’t get how people can stand using the official apps.

Twitter was very friendly to 3rd party developers. But then the big rich guys came in.

You pay $5 for Tweetbot, and they work delivering updates for years before asking for another (usually b/c of many new features or hard work updating the UI for modern iOS)

It's one of the most polished apps around. You don't owe the Developer's time indefinitely from one $5 purchase, and you're free to move to an alternative. I'm happy to continue to support the apps I love -- they generally aren't asking a whole lot.

Additionally, in the case of Twitter clients, they also can't add a lot of new customers b/c Twitter has capped their allowed clients. If they didn't charge customers again, they wouldn't be able to sustain the work with new ones.


Twitter's basic problem is that they opened up to third party clients back while they were still growing, and those third party clients quickly outpaced them in new usage features.

Twitter has been trying to reign that in since (various things their official client can do is not accessible via the public APIs), but they can't just drop their third party support or they would see the usage rates dwindle in no time flat.


The only trouble is that Twitter seems to be taking the opposite approach and blocking third party clients from functioning all together.

http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2011/03/twitte... http://mashable.com/2012/08/16/twitter-api-big-changes/


You are totally misreading the situation. They are FORCED to shut down the product because Twitter just changed their terms of service today and banned all 3rd party apps. There is nothing else to do, there is no "choice" here. 3rd party client apps are not allowed by the API terms of service, that's it.

Do you feel that your Twitter experience isn’t that great as it is when you have some wonderful third party applications around to help you do some of the most exciting things which can’t be enjoyed otherwise?
next

Legal | privacy