Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Those are both towards the beginning of the sentence. Maybe just an "Oops, forgot to capitalize the nouns, better start!" moment? (But sure, the reason they forgot -- if that's what happened -- was most likely that the practice was falling out of common use, and therefore reserved only for fancier Shtuff like Constitutions.)


sort by: page size:

Honestly, I didn't notice that they didn't capitalize things, until it was pointed out.

> why standard practice moved away from capitalizing nouns in the 19th century.

I can't find any reason on google. Got a link?


Many 18th century writers of English capitalized nouns the way it's done in German. For example, the US Constitution does this. But it was already going away by then.

In American English, all of those should be capitalized. I assume this was just an editing error.

The lack of capitals at the start of sentences....

Proper capitalization would have made it clearer.

Yes, I think there is a fair number of people who don’t know that some nouns should be capitalized.

I think they are complaining about the capitalization.

What's with the absence of capital letters?

Also, the weird English custom to capitalize most words in titles, but not in normal sentences, adds to the confusion here.

> Capitalization of proper nouns is a core semantic feature of English.

It is a core spelling rule of English. They could have gone the German way, with all nouns capitalised and compound words without spaces.


Whoops, I didn't notice that the two L's were still capitalized in the normalization example a few comments up.

Capitalization isn't part of grammar. Those examples are different strings of characters altogether.

Capitalization is part of orthography, not grammar.

It bothers me; lack of capitalization makes me think a person didn't care enough to read over what they wrote even if it is just looking at the text as they write it.

Why are so many of those words capitalised...

To me the intentional lack of capitalization always seemed a little bit pretentious. It's not a big deal and I'm probably just feeling old-fashioned, but I still wonder if it's just a passing fad.

As proper nouns become more common, they first lose any capitalization in the middle of the word, and then finally capitalization of the initial letter. It's human language. It happens.

I am guessing it was a snarky comment on the lack of capitalization, which I would not have noticed otherwise.
next

Legal | privacy