Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Nice web design but this jumped out at me:

(they have 120000 viewpoints):

"Wembley stadium has a capacity of 90,000, so our datapoints could fill Wembley once and still fill another third of the available capacity."

the way this is written adds to confusion rather than enlightens. "another third of the available capacity" makes it sound like there is space left over in wembley i.e. you haven't fully filled it.

I think people know how big 120.000 is, but if you must, just say its more than wembley



sort by: page size:

> I think people know how big 120.000 is, but if you must, just say its more than wembley

Agreed. And if you must compare to a stadium, why not just pick a bigger stadium? You can pack at least 115,000 into Michigan Stadium, which would get you a lot closer than Wembley.

(What's that you say? You've never been to Michigan Stadium? That's probably another reason not to rely on this kind of comparison! I, for example have never been to Wembley and have no idea how big it is.)


> m packed sports stadiums, you're still only around ~50k humans max

Nitpick, but there are 8 stadiums (college football) in the United States with a capacity of over 100,000


It says "volume of twelve stadiums" so maybe by treating an entire stadium as a giant bowl up to the top of the seating? But who knows what stadium is the reference stadium - that's not a consistent thing like the size of a football field.

I agree, especially when I read this: "Cowboys stadium has an internal volume of approximately 104 cubic feet"

Somebody left out a "million" somewhere.


> only a football stadium

To be fair, Sanford Stadium seats almost 93,000 (9th largest in US). ;-) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._stadiums_by_cap...

PS: Game day parking and traffic sucked, as someone who lived there.


I think you're reacting more to the words that the author chose than the actual design decision, which is simply an instance of arena allocation.

In the UK, they used to use the volume of Wembley Stadium (a well-known sports ground), but then it was demolished and rebuilt.

I was curious how much bigger the real stadium parking was.

SimCity: https://oyster.ignimgs.com/mediawiki/apis.ign.com/simcity/e/...

Real Stadium: https://i.imgur.com/KwT1T53.png


Such meaningless comparisons also often have the opposite of the desired effect. I read it and went "there are >8 billion people all over the planet, and you can fit all the possible viewports into a single football stadium. Neat!"

Stadiums remain pretty full in my anecdotal experience, so while they may have priced out the general public, they don't fit anyway.

Well on the timeline of the development of large stadiums, I offer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circus_Maximus (and it's worth noting its size in relation to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_stadiums_by_capacity)

I think it would be more accurate to say it’s the size of a football field than a stadium.

It’s a terrible thought, and no disrespect is intended, but a large football stadium holds roughly 100,000 people. So a million people is about 10 large football stadiums. That seems like a reasonable way to comprehend the size and the amount of loss.

35,000 is about the capacity of a medium sized football stadium.

I'd love to see how they manage parking.

I'm also a little curious on how to compare capacities. Per wikipedia, it is only 25k for sports. 70+k for teams is common in many of the other stadiums I looked at. That said, I don't exactly know that many stadiums. Very intimidating to see how large many of these places are.


Massive side not - I have no idea why you guys insist on using football stadiums and football fields as a unit of measurement, what gives?

It’s fine, but it means that the revenue generating projections from sports teams are reflecting the amount of diverted entertainment spending, not net new money. And the frame is often the latter, which is both wrong and deceptive.

If teams presented their cases more truthfully - this stadium won’t make any more money than other options, but the people of this city like sports, so please subsidize the rich owners- I would have less of an issue.

(Said from San Diego, where this former chargers fan is ecstatic to see the city didn’t kowtow to the team’s demands for a new stadium. They are now in LA, and I get 16 Sundays per year back into my life. )


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_football_stadiums_in_G...

Edit: Sorry, I read your comment to quickly, thought you were saying, that there are only 5-6 stadiums that big in Germany.


Anecdotally: 640 sqr feet around Stadium station is about 2300 CDN/mo.
next

Legal | privacy