Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Yes, Apple would have probably replaced it with a new one on the first visit. It sounds like the "repair shop" is milking you.


sort by: page size:

No. They had it for a week and called me back in to pick it up. The replacement (as far as I understand) is not done at the Apple store.

If that happened to me I would probably have Apple either fix it or give me a new one, but you could throw it away if you wanted.

Take it to an Apple Store and have it replaced. Seriously, that isn’t a normal experience.

I’m sure the Apple Store will have replacements for repairs.

> Apple I would just walk into the store and either get it replaced on the spot or serviced and pickup when done.

Not my experience at all.


Off topic but Apple don’t really mind if you buy a new one and then return it after a week once your old one is fixed. Apple support even told my father to do this.

IME Apple will replace an item if they can't fix it after a couple attempts. For example, they tried to fix a laptop of mine and after replacing many internal components, they just provided a replacement.

I would recommend calling AppleCare, asking to speak to a supervisor, and then explaining what's been going on. You might have to try a couple times to get to someone who is sympathetic, but that sure beats waiting for another month and a half!


Pay $550? Why? Apple will do any repair for like $399 (or at least they used to) so long as you didn't mind it being sent out. I guess maybe that answers my question if you needed it back immediately. :)

For future reference, if they botched it the first time, you should call Apple corporate and yell. They messed something up in a repair for my work laptop once and it took one phone call to get a new one immediately. I had to make it clear that it was their fault and I had to have it for work and school, but they were super accommodating (and the new one worked like a charm).


Happened to me... twice.

Both time Apple replaced them quickly with no fuss.


Return it. Apple replaces faulty devices liberally.

Apple's approach is "send it back to us if something is wrong", and more recently, "buy a new one".

I wonder if he took it into an Apple store to have it looked at. Based on the amount of variability it seems like it should be covered by warranty.

No. Apple stores also do repairs

If you bought it less than a month ago there's a pretty good chance that Apple will replace it free of charge (I even got a small refund in one case, when they dropped the price of MacBook Airs at the same time as a hardware refresh).

Interesting, i've always had the experience with Apple that if it was within the 2 week or 30 day(im too lazy to go check) period of having received the device, if there was any issue at all, they'd basically just give you a new one on the spot / take a refund and just buy the exact same model. Edit: YMMV, i might just have been lucky and been dealt with by a very kind apple employee

They'll replace it for you without complaint, but as an Apple Service Provider tech I can tell you, don't get your hopes up about the upgrade. Apple supplies its providers with parts for machines well after their warranties are all up; for a part like that, that's had problems all across the board, doubly so.

Or just a case of bad hardware from the factory. QC is run by humans and sometimes out of spec (aka busted) hardware makes it out of the factory. Was your replacement covered by Apple care?

Have you actually brought a device to be repaired within the last few years?

They take it in the back to diagnose it, come back with a sad expression and tell you they need to send it in, and you can pick it up in a week. (And that's not even mentioning the fact that most Apple stores are a zoo, and you can easily spend an hour waiting for your 'Genius' appointment)


Yes this is why I had to have a full replacement. Apparently Apple have to return the unit to their factory (in China?) to be stripped and reused.
next

Legal | privacy