Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Maybe, it’s better than Google maps though and that is what matters here


sort by: page size:

Who thinks it's better than Google maps?

Well, that's reason enough for me to prefer Google Maps.

Maybe in the US, but I still find Google maps to be far better in Europe

It's a shame google maps is so much better than the alternatives, but it's probably somewhat related to the amount of data they collect.

It's not really the best, though. The article cited to back that up compares Google only to Apple maps and almost entirely focuses on building shapes which add little useful information to the map. Proper street geometry seems more important to begin with.

Not while everyone uses Google Maps reviews it isn't.

You really believes this holds any competition against Google maps?

It's not like Google Maps has a good UI for anything else it does, so doesn't seem to be a knock against the idea.

No, it absolutely doesn't. However there were maps before Google Maps, not even bad ones. The greatness of Google Maps: a, satellite images; b, near-live traffic data; c, geotagged images. Oh, wait, the third is gone, and the second is not thanks to Google but to a startup they bought ;)

I prefer the results it provides over googles these days. Where it falls short is on maps.

Fair enough. Google Maps is actually pretty solid and usually there.

Last time that I checked google maps was vastly superior in all the aspects.

No, it's the future of maps, not Google Maps.

All of that makes it distinctly inferior to Google maps, which is why I'm not sure if any of these approaches is better in absolute terms.

You might be right, but most of those reasons don’t actually matter. To be frank, the only things I miss when not using Google maps is their highlighting of high activity areas.

Both maps have similarly good cartography where it matters. In most countries, both maps are similarly accurate.


Yes, sorry, it could help other competitors to Google, like other mapping companies

Hadn't heard about that. Still works better than Google maps, though - not that I'm making much of a claim by saying so. I cannot imagine what the designers of the current Google maps site were thinking.

Yeah I get that, you might like Google maps more if say you cared about the actual maps.

Yes, but which DMV?

I kid, but honestly, Google Maps is just so much better.

next

Legal | privacy