Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

You know what? You might be right. However, Verizon seemed to pitch it as some sort of "brain" when I was there. At least, they definitely implied the transistor originated there. But thank you for clarification. Always appreciated.


sort by: page size:

This sounds like they reinvented the transistor?

Bell Labs, where the transistor was discovered, did exactly what you suggest, so maybe the transistor did actually appear 10 years early. It's famous for letting its scientists concentrate on research without concern for commercial uses.

I love that. It’s funny, though – I know the transistor is “little” compared to the vacuum tube, but look at it next to an actual brain cell and it’s enormous!

Even if this is the case, at first people were scratching their head looking at the transistor what it might be good for.

The patent doesn't mention the term "transistor"; but obviously the patent office came to the conclusion that it is a patentable invention, and the cited by list confirms that it is considered a relevant invention by Bell Labs and other notable institutions. Prior art by Lilienfeld did even stop some applications of Bell Labs from going forward. The transistor invented in 1947 was a point-contact transistor, which is not the concept applied in micro processors as the article confirms.

Intriguing. Mind if I inquire about your thoughts on transistors, another Bell Labs creation?

To be fair, there were plenty of people working into creating a transistor, so if Bell Labs weren't there, somebody else would have done it. It is not even clear that they were really the first.

I believe the transistor was invented at Bell Labs, though Shockley was involved in the invention

To be fair, they predict that transistors will be everywhere including places where they (mostly) aren't found today such as in our bodies and close to our food.

I would take that bet, too. If you say “transistor” to non-technical people over 50 or so, they more likely would think of small portable radios (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor_radio). To them, and many others, computers don’t have transistors, they have chips.

They _might_ know the transistor replaced vacuum tubes, but I doubt many would be able to tell what function either had, or be able to point out the transistors inside such a radio.


FTA: "The Nazis introduced the Volksempfänger, a cheap wireless transistor set, to broadcast Hitler’s speeches ...."

Highly doubtful it was a transistor set, inasmuch as the first working transistor wasn't invented until 1947, at Bell Labs. [0]

(The underlying point is valid, though. [1])

[0] https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Transistor

[1] https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Volksempf%C3%A4nger


Weren't transistors specifically invented to improve telephone networks?

That's not accurate. AT&T dominated telecommunications for decades before the transistor. Many of Bell Labs great scientific inventions predate the transistor, such as information theory.

The first transistor was about the size of a Raspberry Pi but I think your point still stands.

You're assuming that nowhere in the entire universe of trillions of planets did a transistor get created before then?

Bell Labs invented the transistor!

Why did you think that? We didn't have transistors until the 1960s.

That's not how I read your comment. It clearly tries to suggest that when the transistor was first invented people did not know what to do with it.

I think the MASER/LASER would have been a far better example.


Likewise, AT&T licensed the transistor to a small Japanese startup and told them it would probably only be useful for making a hearing aid. Fortunately, Sony had a knack for finding consumer applications of the device and humanity now makes quadrillions of transistors every year.
next

Legal | privacy