Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Elections where candidates are murdered or barred from participating? Those aren’t elections.


sort by: page size:

Don't they have elections for that purpose?

There aren't regular Cosa Nostra elections.

Officials are not democratically elected.

This is so weird, because you could also just not elect them.

local election held outside the regularly scheduled cadence, usually because the incumbent resigned or died

I don't think there'll be elections soon.

They still have elections.

By that standard, the president of the US isn't elected either.

In many organizations with a "NOTA" option in their elections, if NOTA wins then the election is held over again with none of the previous candidates eligible to run.

Yeah, but the givernment controls the institution that runs those elections... it’s a completely frigged system. So you statement is moot.

Elections are coming soon.

Can't prosecute the voters if you want to be reelected.


Elected positions might be wackadoo but they’re not random. Their refusal to seat a duly elected candidate for office is not valid legally and it’s not valid as a principled rejection of governing structure they object to. They could (however undemocratically) try to eliminate the role. But they can’t just ignore the election because it doesn’t suit them, without scrutiny.

Not in an election year.

Are there any laws against electing a dead person?

they aren't elected

When "none of the above" wins, it usually means new elections where all old candidates are banned or some other procedure to resolve complete distrust to current politicians.

That is exactly the point. Holding elections, even peaceful, transparent elections, is not the same thing as "replacing the government." Most government employees and non-employees who heavily influence policy are not elected and can't be replaced through elections.

Then why bother with elections? Be transparent and just appoint them.

The alternative is a country where political candidates are not bound by the rule of law.

That juice is not worth the squeeze.

next

Legal | privacy