Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

You can't just put anything in a contract and expect a judge to enforce it.

Contracts have limits determined by statutes and common law. People also have rights that they legally can't give away in a contract.



sort by: page size:

You can put anything in a contract, but that doesn't make the contract enforceable. And the way our legal system is set up, you can't challenge the legality of a contract clause without (someone) entering into it.

A contract can say any thing but courts will enforce only certain things.

Contracts can't enforce themselves.

Anything not enforceable shouldn't be in the contract in the first place. The only purpose of contracts is to enforce earlier promises when people don't agree anymore.

You can add anything you want to a contract, but that doesn't mean the courts will uphold it.

Also, even court enforcement of contracts has its limits - you just go outside the borders of a country, and they can't (easily) make you fulfill your contract.

That said, I am all for court enforcement of contracts. In fact, I wish that the courts would respect, if not enforce, far more contracts than they do.


Why is that you, and other people here, are treating a contract like it's law? Companies can put pretty much anything they want in a contract, it does not mean its enforceable. You have to take into account your jurisdiction.

OK, but courts can and do rule that certain provisions of contracts are not enforceable.

That's not how contracts work; just because you CAN sue someone doesn't mean you MUST. Nor does not enforcing against one party mean they can't against another.

You can put anything you want in a contract, the question is, is it enforceable?

You can't make a contract that violates the law. Come on.

Most contracts limit a party's rights without giving everything in exchange.

Generally it's not enforceable but plenty of people don't know how contract law works.

By this logic, anything is enforceable because some people will think it's enforceable. Your point is a valid one, but it's also good to tell everyone that these contracts are not legally enforceable!

A contract is a list of demands (amongst other things). It can't be enforced until you agree to the contract. Until then it's just a demand.

You realize that contracts can't contain illegal clauses right? They aren't enforceable in any court.

If you can't enforce a contract it's not a contract.

You can put anything in a contract or legal document. Doesn’t mean that it’s enforceable or can be upheld in a court of law.

Contractual agreements are enforceable at law. That's what makes them contracts.
next

Legal | privacy