Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Huh? So anyone who asks/says something in OSS, should just throw money into the ring to have an opinion?


sort by: page size:

well that opinion is expressed by people who want nearly zero opinion OSs.

Here's one of my opinions: Everything anyone ever says is their own opinion based on their own experiences.

Here's another: We'd all be better off if we held the opinion above, and remembered it when assessing what people say. We'd be able to interpret statements like "Contributing to OSS is awesome!" as "In my own experience, contributing to OSS has been awesome", where such an interpretation doesn't erase or override one's own opinions and experiences. Not saying this is easy to do, just that it is beneficial.


And who are you to decided that? How about people who demonstrate incredibly judgemental behaviour such as yourself, do you have a place in OSS... and is somehow qualified to judge who else does? Don't think so.

"This is wrong and I won't tell you why" is not very valuable; opinions are ten-a-penny on the internet.

I think it's toxic to suggest your way or ideas are better without giving people any way to verify that they are. Of course anyone can have an opinion about anything.

Anyone can have any opinion they want to have.

But when they make it based on a flawed claim, like, "I can get an email account without first picking a server," don't you think it's better if they understand that their claim was false?


Are you being paid for your opinion?

What an oxymoron. This is a FORUM. People are supposed to voice their opinions.

You can have any opinion you want. But it may not be worth much.

Only if the opinion of the people you ask is considered valuable.

As… having an opinion? Not earning hundreds of millions of dollars?

Well there people who disagree and would like to invest in them. Why should your opinion be forced on them?

If they want their view heard, they're welcome to share it like everyone else.

Paying someone else to share a very sanitized, market researched version of your opinion while pretending that they're organically sharing their own opinion isn't that. It's dishonest, and it's eroding honest conversations for the sake of advertising.


Yeah, but all you said was "if you didn't work on X, you can't have an opinion about X", which is a completely useless and trivially wrong statement.

Some people don't like opinions. They just want to be told what to do. Especially when it comes together with a salary.

If that's the case, then yeah fair enough. If someone doesn't want your opinion they shouldn't ask for it.

You're missing the point. Why do you think you get a say in whether their opinion has any weight? As of right now their opinion of how it should work IS how it works until all of their wasteful bytes are rendering and animating in your face.

For their opinion?

Does it matter if they don't? People are entitled to opinions which may seem absurd. https://github.com/prettydiff/wisdom/blob/master/Avoiding_Tr...
next

Legal | privacy