Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

14 minute video? Why? On the homepage have a video that is 30-60 seconds. here is an example http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFcZjtGS1CE

Otherwise looks good.



sort by: page size:

Came across a video on YouTube recently that I think may be misreporting its length due to this issue:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Grsvyt5xps

The video is 22 minutes but it's reported at nearly 3 hours in length.


Funny... I got the message that I could upload longer videos, but the bullet points next to the upload button still say "Shorter than 15 minutes."

A lot of this is actually caused by Google in benefiting observability of videos that are longer so they (google) can show more ads. You either get a 60 second short, or 10ish minutes. This leads content creators to stretch out their videos longer than they really should be.

I was a bit confused why it had to be under 15 minutes as I didn't know there was a limit, apparently you can increase it. https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/71673?hl=en

Relevant : 10/20/30 rule for Powerpoint presentation. Which says to take only 20 minutes for your presentation.

https://www.pier8group.com/the-10-20-30-rule-of-powerpoint/

On youtube I find any video over 8 minutes as boringly long. Needs skipped in the mid.


Why would you do a 10 minutes introduction video ! I can't watch anything longer than 2 minutes.

If I recall correctly there's a certain length videos need to be to get adverts or to be monetised - something like ~10 minutes. So while this one is a little bit played out (maybe this happens to get an extra set of ads in the middle) the worst are when you have 2-3 minutes of information streeeeeetched out to 10 minutes.

OK, I see. so is there a 15 second limit on the videos?

I bought a UX course several years ago. Each video was over an hour.

The creator later redid all the videos, cutting them into shorter videos no longer than 9 minutes. He stated the reason was because this was one of the top requests from students.


We're actually seeing the exact opposite on blip.tv. Average video length on our site of popular content is about 13 minutes.

that's also different for everyone. I needed a 12 minutes and 13 seconds video

Videos are great as a supplement but they should be kept to 1 minute. Mine is 1:30 and it's still longer than I'd like.

In case you're hesitating to click on a video link: it's only 10 mins long.

Also note you can speed it up. I usually watch YouTube on 1.5 speed, so this is a 12 minute video for me ;-)

I wish people were a bit more concise when making video content.

I watched that embedded video at 2x and it was still a drag.

There's times to make videos long, but not like that


No shit, with Youtube favoring longer videos content creators need to pan out the running time.

There is quite some value in longer videos.

However there seems to be a thing that you need 10 minutes for monetisation, so people stretch content not needing much time to those 10 minutes ...


The length of content on YouTube is a bit weird for me. I don't like Shorts, for multiple reasons, but length is one of them. It's hard to do meaningful content in less than one minute. Some are able to and make good stuff though. I also don't like 20 minute videos, because they seem to be mostly stretched to facilitate monetization and ads. 10 minutes is the sweet spot for me, but that's not longer viable for the creators.

Your https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcFQeimLH1c is a 4.5-hour video, the first 5 minutes of which shows a completely static video track with an audio track of a guy talking slowly.
next

Legal | privacy