Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Maybe the maps could auto update using a combination of

>magnetic data plus wifi data plus user behavior data



sort by: page size:

Every phone using the app can contribute to your map data. If you combine magnetic data plus wifi data plus user behavior data, I expect you'd be able to continue to provide good 3D data to users.

I'd bet the hard part is getting building owners to update things regularly. Who's going to remember to change the map when the grocery store moves the cereal from aisle 2 to aisle 7?


I get a popup/notification once a month or so, when on wifi. It just asks if I want an update. There are settings to automatically update offline maps and one to control the automatic downloading of offline maps.

Seems pretty reasonable to me, after all roads do change over time.

My main motivation is to make nav less bandwidth intensive (I pay per GB with Google FI) and to ensure I have maps even if I don't have a good data connection.


Google maps on Android lets me do something like this. It will occasionally prompt me to update the map with new data.

I love OrganicMaps but lacks in certain situations.

When I want to be able to zoom into any and all of my bookmarks, I have to keep the map data of all countries I've ever been visiting. Thats tens and tens of GB of data on a mobile phone.

And everytime there are maps updates I have to redownload all of it. Tens and tens of GB of data.

When you're traveling and forgot to DL everythibg beforehand and have to use some WIFI hotspot you might not be able to get your maps downloaded. Happened to me multiple times.

So, my feature request:

- smaller maps data

- incremental updates

- online maps

...oh and better search of course. ;)


I am surprised that that don't have an offline version for the maps. The location of the charge station does not change that often, operational status might, but few hours stale data should still be sufficient to navigate.

I think they must be release a map/navigation app by using this data.

Map data will certainly be updated constantly, not even requiring an update to the app. Any time there's a road closure or the map changes in some way, it needs to be reflected live. So I wouldn't be surprised if other aspects of the map are updated server-side as well.

I'm pretty sure maps uses data from a few sources, one being how fast android devices are moving near there.

Hardly an impossible feature to add to a mapping product tho? We are basically talking downloading the map tiles to the device you want to browse from.

I would think that it would not gather (as much) data when using it for offline maps. I admit it's just an hope.

They would probably provide caching, which is what the current map application does. Hopefully they will let you pre-cache areas, such as you can do in Android, but I doubt it. Anyway, no point speculating too much.

Now that is a feature. I'd happily download my home town and run it offline always. Waiting for 3g cell reception to get the map to see where you're to go next is very tedious.

I think there's a place for offline maps, both in terms of connection reliability and privacy.

Not to derail the topic - but maps already does that.

Search for your area. Pull up info sheet for it. Click "Save map to use offline". (Although I've got no idea if it checks for changes)


More reliable map data to compete against Google Maps w/ wifi location assist?

Dont forget about Google latitude. That needs to get implemented directly with maps. So I wouldnt expect to see that as well.

Yes, there's two settings in maps under offline maps. You can set it to auto update and download if you wish.

Now imagine if Tomtom and Microsoft both paid users for map improvements. That would be super cool.

They could even make an app to submit the improvements and even show me ads, I don't care. I would still do it.


I hope so, as this will enable Google Maps-like functionality.
next

Legal | privacy