Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

But why not violate its own laws? Countries make and break their own laws all the time? Cops drive through red lights by flicking on their lights for a minute, surely a country can wave him onto a plane without checking his papers.


sort by: page size:

Not every country has the same laws as every other country.

That makes sense to me. Which actions show they’re violating any law in any country?

Well, if you go to another country and you don't know the laws, you will still get arrested if you break the law.

Almost everything violates some laws in some country.

The one with broken international laws?

Country's laws are a bit different, simply because a country has virtually absolute legal power over its territory. Countries can and do punish people for breaking laws that one cannot feasibly know they were breaking. Does any human know all the laws in the United States? Would that even be physically possible?

Consider that there are many other countries than the US, where laws are often oppressive and should be broken.

Is that really true? My understanding for example in the USA is that if you violate the laws in another country, you automatically violate the laws in the USA (under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act - https://www.justice.gov/criminal-fraud/foreign-corrupt-pract...) - or is that really just limited to bribery? AFAIK some other countries have similar provisions.

A country claiming its law is enforceable everywhere does not make it so.

How exactly do they do that? Do they extend the american laws outside our borders and let our police raid international sites without international knowledge/assistance?

Mainly because our laws are voted on by our own citizens and because the rest of the world doesn't accept our laws and doesn't have a say in creating them. Your statement seems nonsensical.

If there is an action that breaks the law of two countries there can be joint law enforcement activities. The US cannot punish actions that are legal in one country but illegal in the United States by acting in that foreign country.


In countries that follow the rule of law, they are not.

It probably violates the laws of these countries as well, and international cooperation on such cases is common.

Not in some countries, because they have actual enforcement of the law.

Newsflash: There are more countries than the US of A and your laws do not apply here.

Different country, culture and enforcement of laws.

The law broken was a US law which 'applies worldwide'. The actual supposed crime occurred in a trade between China and Iran.

No other country could make a law like that and have any success in enforcing it abroad.


The point is more about what could happen when breaking laws in other countries than what did happen in this particular case.

No country does that, they just set examples of people who break draconian laws, which is effective as long as you don't count all the people trying to leave the country.

Or maybe because different countries have different laws.
next

Legal | privacy