Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

If they work for Google, I wish they'd say so in their HN profile, or a comment. And if they don't, they should probably clear that up, too.


sort by: page size:

It’s not clear to me from their comment that they actually work at Google.

People commenting on this who work for google or hope to probably should say so in their comment.

No they aren't. Plenty of people here know someone who works at Google.

I've mentioned a number of times i work for google, and try to do so when appropriate. I removed it from my HN profile after I started getting folks bringing it up randomly.

I regularly am discussing Google's business with Googlers on here. Some of them disclose in the post, some of them disclose on their HN profile. Many do not, and calling them on it is generally discouraged, but it's usually not super hard to figure out or prove.

There are definitely some acting as spokespeople (even if they claim otherwise), but there are also quite a few who are just, you know, incredibly biased fans of their employer, who like to defend them on topics unrelated to their job.

But when a tech company has 100,000 employees, it's not particularly surprising to see a good number of them on a tech forum. ;)


If people comment and don't say they're Google employees, how do you know they're Google employees?

Did I miss the place on this thread where the person we're talking about said they worked for Google?

"but they never bother to mention as much as their function or position within Google."

And even if they did how do you even know that info is true? Who verifies that?


Not a high bar. Their profile says they work at Google, hence my comment. They’re wrong about what Google HR is doing, apparently.

If a commenter on HN says something about Google, wouldn't you take his/her comment more seriously if you know that he/she is a Google employee?

Do you work at Google or is that an assumption?

Agreed. Seems like a conflict of interest. I'd very much appreciate any Googler outright stating as such at even the slightest mention of their employer, and doubly so when recommend Google products.

It would be hypocritical of me to not do as I ask of others, so for the record: I'm a self-employed programming consultant.


ironically it achieves the opposite, when someone declares themselves a Googler I assume they're biased (you are, uncontrollably) and disregard it

it's not a legal requirement, I mean maybe they say it is, but it's bogus...

on a deeper level, I honestly think it's an unintentional brag... if I mention my notable employer it scratches a little itch

if you really want to put on a tinfoil hat, they're one of the world's largest advertisers and are pleased as peach if their employees just walk around telling everyone they meet that they work at google


Er, who do you think works for Google here?

You should disclose whether you work for Google. You've registered less than 24 hours ago and in all of your posts you defend Google.

You’re right though

Disclosure: I work for Google


Agreed, not everyone works for google.

This seems really off to me. Mentioning that you work for Google only seems to introduce the risk that your words would be taken to represent Google. There’s a post in this thread where someone mentions they work for Google but fails to include the “opinions are my own” disclaimer.

They said someone at Google, not everyone at Google.
next

Legal | privacy