Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Or skip the desalinated water and grow Salicornia bigelovii with straight seawater or runoff water or aquaculture wastewater.


sort by: page size:

I seriously doubt that except fresh produce in some hellishly hot desert country large scale agriculture using desalinated water makes sense. Much less so if you don't grow some cash crops but have to process it then transport the final product.

There are almost "miracle plants" like Salicornia which can be watered with sea water, but these do not have growth rates of more picky plants like corn or hemp.


If you had a lot of fresh water runoff, you might use that fresh water for drinking rather than desalinating seawater though.

But... If you are using this water for drinking, it's going to come back through the sewage system, and maybe you can dilute the brine with outflows from local sewage treatment plants.

Depending on details, the combined outflow could be more or less salty than the seawater input to the desal plant.


It may be better to just treat the waste water and skip the desalination in that case.

Where are you going to get the water from?

If it's seawater, how are you going to return it to the ocean. You can't dump salt water on land -- it poisons the soil. Even freshwater evaporating in dry climates leads to salinization.

What's that going to cost you in energy inputs (pumping costs)?

Though the thought occurs to me that the Salton Sea in southern California might make a possibly suitable grow region.


You can use desalination for drinking water, but growing food requires way too much water for it to be feasible.

Pretty sure you need fresh water rather than salt water for that. And desalination is an energy-expensive process.

Have you considered wastewater recycling? It's more energy efficient than desalination and doesn't require a pipe to the ocean!

Adding desalination plants is a great solution.

Salt-water is highly corrosive, you can't use salt-water to power the whole plant. You still need a pure water source.

Your post mentions desalinated water, how are you dealing with the desalination byproducts (very salty water I assume)?

If you need a desal plant, probably not a lot of water laying around to dilute your brine stream

Desalinate water near the coasts, maybe.

Also take into account the much bigger amount that is needed to grow crops and feed livestock; you may be able to use graywater for that, but definitely not saltwater.

Also, water needed by industries and water spoiled by pollution.


Curious: are you suggesting that sea water can be used on crops? If so, how?

We call them “desalination” plants, but the salt doesn’t just disappear. The more fresh water you have them produce, the more salt (brackish water) you need to manage as well.

So even while you may imagine the ocean as a limitless supply of water, there’s only so far you can scale desalination.


IIUC this use the solar power to filter the water, and then it is cultivated in pots or hydroponic or something. So it doesn't matter if the structure is on non arable land or over water.

Being over water simplifies the pipes, but you must be sure that the device floats, this is not so easy, small ships sunk very often and need a lot of maintenance, specially in salty water.

Also, the dome/jellyfish shape is nice, but the light each plant gets is smaller, in a flat surface each plan gets more light. The plants essentially convert sunlight into food, so more sunlight is better.

And most commercial plantation relay in very cheap (or free) water. Any filtration to use salty or polluted water will increase the cost of production.


Looks great, good luck! Question about the seawater aspect, are ecological impacts similar to conventional desalination processes?

Desalinating sea water in order to replenish the sweet water reserves we ourselves have degraded with unsustainable practices is pure madness.

What needs to be done instead is to stop interfering with the water cycle [0], let rain water infiltrate the ground, recharge aquifers and restore soil moisture. In order to do that we need to stop the habit of making the ground impermeable (with cement and tar), and stop sending rain water to the sewers to be thrown back to the ocean, and then plant trees. Lots and lots of trees.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_cycle


Pump seawater to Nevada and cover it in desalination greenhouses. http://www.seawatergreenhouse.com/
next

Legal | privacy