Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

I should have said "(nearly) everyone reading on Hacker News wants..."

He's complaining to the choir (of sorts) while disparaging the very real progress we are making because it isn't as good as it could have possibly been if reality were different.



sort by: page size:

> So seriously, Hacker News, what is the obsession with this?

We are optimists, we think there is always something that could be improved.


> This attitude is strangely pervasive on Hacker News, and it's very annoying.

Hard and annoying.


> "This is hacker news, where people are trying to do difficult things to change the world."

Hahaha, I say this partially in jest, but Hacker News is basically for people to bash on dreamers' ideas.


As a Hacker News denizen I exercise my prerogative to complain about anything and everything possible, as long as there's some technical merit to it.

I'd really like to start seeing less of this sort of comment on Hacker News. It's not even close to literally true.

Yeah my comment isn't about the substance of the article (I read it and don't have any complaints) it's just a general complaint about the concepts mentioned in the title.

And yes, I know this is a classic hacker news trope, I just couldn't help myself


I thought this was an exceptionally well-written, nuanced article and your comment, to me, just reads like typical Hacker News complaining.

I love hacker news, complaining about semantics when someone says most people are having their lives ruined with the clap back that it's only 40% is the best possible reply!

> Hahaha, I say this partially in jest, but Hacker News is basically for people to bash on dreamers' ideas.

I completely agree, though I prefer to look at it as "constructive criticism" of every flavor.


>Reading hacker news

- It's bad


Sadly, I'd expect this from hacker news commenters.

So the totality of your criticism of a story from one of the best security reporters in the business is sigh and "doesn't get it right"?

And this is the top comment on Hacker News?

Sigh


The joy of Hackernews is that there is always someone to complain.

Says the poster in "Hacker News"

> He has scratched the iceberg of skepticism and now thinks he's enough of an expert to tell the rest of us that we're Doing It Wrong.

This sort of gratuitous negativity isn't appropriate in a Hacker News comment. It is unnecessary to make your point and pollutes the atmosphere for all of us. Please don't do that.


> So seriously, Hacker News, what is the obsession with this?

We are dilettantes, we think there is always something that could be improved in a domain we don't fully understand.


> I hope he doesn't read Hacker News.

I hope he does, it's a good measure of the average hacker.


> There is a lot of technology work [...] that improves peoples' lives in immensely meaningful ways. The problem is that you never hear about it on Hacker News.

Why don't you post some articles about it, then? I believe this community would love nothing better than to learn about immensely meaningful technical work that they've never heard about. I know I would.


"I imagine that if this article makes its way onto Hacker News, I will be criticized."
next

Legal | privacy