Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

>Journals only publish so many papers in a given time. Its not just a matter of submitting a good enough paper.

And how does that happen without any staff evaluating papers, as you claimed above?



view as:

Could you stop faking to be an idiot, please? We already responded to that question and you know it.

ufo claimed above that "The only thing the publisher does is own the name of the prestigious journal."

This is false. Why is calling them on it now "faking to be an idiot"?

I pointed out that there's curation, and that imposes costs. Denying that it exists doesn't help.


Pfffffff.

Once again: the curation is not performed by the publisher, but by the editorial board and the reviewers, who are researchers, and are not paid by the publishers for this work.


A cursory google search turns up plenty of counterexamples.

See http://blog.journals.cambridge.org/2012/06/14/recruiting-a-j... and http://www.sciencemag.org/careers/2002/02/editorial-boards-s...

I'll note that even PLOS medicine wasn't able to get editors for free, as an open access journal http://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/s/competing-interests-...


Paid academic journal editors are rare exceptions.

From one of your own links:

    Carol Barnes, professor of psychology and neurology at the
    University of Arizona in Tucson, is a reviewing editor at
    the Journal of Neuroscience, a 3-year appointment for which
    *she receives no compensation*.
    (…)
    Barnes has received funding from the university to hire an
    assistant to provide clerical support to assist her with
    the manuscript review process. She considers herself
    fortunate, because "without this help, I would have had to
    decline this position."
Not only she was still paid by the university for whats seems to be a full time job during 3 years according to the article, but in addition to that the university, not the publisher, paid for an assistant to this job!

That journal appears to be owned by a non profit.

And I can assure you that the situation is similar with journals owned by Wiley, Springer, and Elsevier, for examples.

Legal | privacy