Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Are deaf people allowed to drive? How do you think they handle these situations?


view as:

According to a quick google, noticing that other cars are pulling in/slowing down usually works if they can't see the emergency vehicle. Still, it's not "perfect", but then Hearing drivers are far from perfect either, and there's plenty of failsafes before an accident happens.

Fire trucks and ambulances I've seen when driving against traffic lights/flow of traffic always slow and stop to make sure that there will not be an accident even if they have the right of way - they don't drive like police in pursuit on TV. I'm sure there are exceptions but the general case is the emergency vehicles are planning for other traffic to not yield until it is clear the other traffic is yielding.

I'm sure there are exceptions but the general case is the emergency vehicles are planning for other traffic to not yield until it is clear the other traffic is yielding.

Yes, if the driver is well trained. When I was firefighting and instructing drivers, we always emphasized that while the red light and siren gave you the right of way:

a. they don't absolve you of liability for a crash (at least under NC law)

and

b. if you get in a crash on the way to the scene, you're not doing anybody any good, PLUS you've now created another incident requiring another emergency response, PLUS another company (probably coming from further away) has to respond to the original call.

I can't speak for police, but firefighters are actually, in my experience, taught to be pretty conservative when it comes to running red lights, proceeding against traffic on one way streets, and other similar scenarios.

We also always used to emphasize "it does no good to get halfway there, real fast".


There seems to be some limited automotive technology available that would convert sirens to visual signals, akin to doorbell or telephone strobes. But the more interesting adaptive technology seems to be a re-wiring of the brain. [0] Deprived of auditory input and with a heightened reliance on visual cues, the autonomous driving version might be something like Lidar + other driver facial recognition.

[0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/superpowers-for-t...


> There seems to be some limited automotive technology available that would convert sirens to visual signals

Yes, I've noticed this too. Sometimes you can almost see blue and red flashing lights on top of a police car.


I applaud your synesthesia! Those of us with more common auditory processing are unable to see sound. :(

si·ren (sir?n)noun 1.a device that makes a loud prolonged sound as a signal or warning.


Per [0] they are allowed to drive in the US, and do not have higher accident rates than hearing drivers[1]. Also, "There are now devices available that can be used in r cars that react to the frequency of sirens and which emit visual warnings of approaching emergency vehicles to assist deaf drivers and those with hearing loss" (which could presumably also "assist" self-driving cars).

[0] https://www.enddd.org/end-distracted-driving/enddd-presentat...

[1] This web site's bona fides aren't clear, but its mission does not seem to specifically include advocating for the deaf, so there's no obvious reason for the information presented to be biased in favor of the deaf.


Legal | privacy