Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

> Large personal vehicles should just be banned in cities.

I see your point, but that will only work when small city cars will be cheap enough to let have a "real" car too for non-daily purposes (long journey, huge shopping, out with the family...).



view as:

Isn't it already the case?

A brand new C1 is about 12K€. That's not even twice the price of an electrified cargo bike (I saw about 7/8K€ floated around the other day).

And if you go for used, you can get cars in good enough shape for less than 5K€.

Obviously, the additional car will have a much higher running cost than if you went for an electrified cargo bike or stuck to a single car. Forcing people to make that conscious choice would be a pro in my opinion.


I admit I fell in a lucky spot, but 12 k€ is just a bit less than what I paid my new Jeep Renegade, so I don't consider it that cheap.

> electrified cargo bike

Hilly area? Taking children to school or old parent to the doctor's? Not a chance!

> stuck to a single car

Yes, the SUV.

Edit:

> if you go for used, you can get cars in good enough shape for less than 5K€.

Yeah, that's nicer. Unfortunately, you have to add insurance and maintenance, plus a parking spot at home. Still too much for people to accept non-tiny cars to be banned from the city.


> Hilly area? Taking children to school or old parent to the doctor's? Not a chance!

https://bikemag.hu/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/P4071422.jpg


Yeah. I've been towing my children to school in a trailer behind my (non-electric) bike. Not particularly difficult, given the route is mostly flat, though I'm grateful it's only a mile and a half each way (I'm old and unfit).

Mind you, there's only one other family that does it. Most people just walk, some drive.


You don't need a large vehicle like an SUV or pick-up truck for those purposes.

You don't strictly need them, but they help a lot.

Legal | privacy