Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

> Many people have been trying to get the point across that legal, unlimited free speech can put people in harm's way.

It would appear, based on empirical evidence, that in practice everyone agrees with this point. That may count as mission success for those many people.

Was free speech absolutism ever something Musk put on the table? The issue that Musk is addressing is Twitter's systemic suppression of right-wing political speech.



view as:

Why yes, he did, eg:

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1519036983137509376

Musk repeatedly said that his aim is to allow anything that's legal. He even promised not to ban this specific account:

https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/c_fit,f_au...


Isn't he suing the person behind the tracking thing? Musk thinks this is against the law, so he isn't being inconsistent with that tweet.

But even if he was, one tweet isn't really much of a commitment. People throw out tweets they don't mean all the time. 140 characters isn't enough to lay out an ideological position. Running a company like twitter is a bit more serious - they can't moderate just based on interpretations of what Elon tweets. And they were never going to.

Although if he was committing to keeping the plane account around he is definitely didn't think that through.


> Isn't he suing the person behind the tracking thing? Musk thinks this is against the law, so he isn't being inconsistent with that tweet.

You can sue anyone for anything. If you're going to say that only illegal things don't belong, you should wait for the legal system to produce a judgment.

> But even if he was, one tweet isn't really much of a commitment. People throw out tweets they don't mean all the time.

He's said it multiple times. If you don't mean it, how about you just don't say it?

> Running a company like twitter is a bit more serious - they can't moderate just based on interpretations of what Elon tweets. And they were never going to.

Except so far that's exactly what is happening. Musk promised "free speech", so far everything indicates that in reality what we get is "Elon rules". In the end it's simply about what he wants, nothing more.

Mind, I fully agree he's got the right to do anything he wants. It's his site now. I'm just pointing out the inconsistency.


Legal | privacy