Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

just because it doesn't have acres of sand, doesn't mean its not desert - large portions of California are just that - Semi Arid Plains


sort by: page size:

California deserts arent sand dune heavy. Instead it is shrubs with their own ecosystem.

It might not technically be a desert, but saying it's "far from" is incorrect too. Semi-arid climate zones are as close to deserts as you can be without actually being a desert. For recreational purposes in particular, people tend to look mostly for open water or mountains, sometimes forests or canyons. Miles and miles of "scrubby prairie" lacking any of those might as well be a desert.

LA actually isn’t a desert, although there is desert in the LA area. Most of LA is classified as Mediterranean, and gets enough rain (the closer to the coast, the less deserty it is). Lots of mountains make for interesting climate zones.

No, LA is not a desert. The desert (e.g., the Mojave) is over on the other side of the mountains. Coastal Southern California is not a desert.

Here’s a blog by a couple of LA friends about the partly-covered LA creek network: https://lacreekfreak.wordpress.com


Minor nitpick as an amateur green thumb, but depending on where you're talking about in southern California, coastal California is a Chaparral ecoregion [1], characterized by a high density of shrubs. A desert has lower plant density. It irks me when people in the Bay Area and LA go full desert xeriscape because a) the plants are not adapted for those environments b) animals are less adapted to those plants and c) the exposed sand does little to locally cool the area, unlike native plants

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_coastal_sage_and_ch...


That's more of a dustbowl caused by deforestation - doesn't have the arid (or semi-arid) climate of a true desert.

The Osoyoos "desert" isn't really arid enough, either.

Deserts don't have to look like sand dunes, they are any area with a low rainfall. Sometimes the plants that are adapted are virtually a forest, but it's still a desert. For example in the Baja California desert: https://mbgecologicalrestoration.files.wordpress.com/2015/03...


It's covered in the article. It does fall into the classification of a semi-arid desert.

Deserts in the US are not the Sahara - they are large, flat open spaces of hard ground and sagebrush. I'm sure there are still challenges, but if you are envisioning sand dunes to all horizons, that isn't what our deserts look like.

Not sure why you're being downvoted, there definitely is a lot of agriculture in the California and Arizona deserts.

They call it a "desert" because there are sand dunes, not because it is actually a desert[1]. Receives more rain than the Silicon Valley.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carcross_Desert


It says receiving less than which is not 50cm. Further, semi arid desert is defined as less than 50cm. Really Palo Alto like much of California is semi arid, just look at the native plant life. Check out the map: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semi-arid_climate vs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desert_climate

The US has very little desert in the Sahara or Saudi Arabia style of nothing but sand and rocks. Most desert areas in the US are covered in cactus, brush, and grasses.

That’s not in a desert though.

It's a real desert.

That as well. You don't think of it that way, but the place is arid.

Why do you think the Central Valley in CA is a desert?

I agree that CA agriculture needs to be more careful with how it uses almonds, but the Valley is not a desert, it's a great place to grow crops.


> by the Okanagan Desert, a semi-arid region

aren't deserts defined by being arid regions?


> Most of the "empty" space on the map world is an inhospitable desert.

Southern California is an inhospitable desert, but tens of millions of people live there nonetheless.


I’m seriously trying to figure out what state you are talking about. Definitely not California (cities aren’t very near the desert, even Los Angeles is in a semi humid basin), Arizona doesn’t have lawns mostly, Utah SLC wouldn’t really qualify as desert either. So then I thought you might mean Saudi Arabia?
next

Legal | privacy