Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

It might not technically be a desert, but saying it's "far from" is incorrect too. Semi-arid climate zones are as close to deserts as you can be without actually being a desert. For recreational purposes in particular, people tend to look mostly for open water or mountains, sometimes forests or canyons. Miles and miles of "scrubby prairie" lacking any of those might as well be a desert.


sort by: page size:

It's covered in the article. It does fall into the classification of a semi-arid desert.

just because it doesn't have acres of sand, doesn't mean its not desert - large portions of California are just that - Semi Arid Plains

> by the Okanagan Desert, a semi-arid region

aren't deserts defined by being arid regions?


It's a real desert.

That’s not in a desert though.

Hah there are no deserts for more than 10h driving from Austin. It's rolling hills and scrubby prairie, which is far from a desert.

Desert.

i think it's akin to saying antarctica is a desert as well

Deserts in the US are not the Sahara - they are large, flat open spaces of hard ground and sagebrush. I'm sure there are still challenges, but if you are envisioning sand dunes to all horizons, that isn't what our deserts look like.

yes, however, having a river does not make the area something other than a desert.

That as well. You don't think of it that way, but the place is arid.

The definition of "desert" only refers to precipitation amounts, not aridity. Water is still available via lakes, reservoirs, rivers, springs, groundwater, etc.

Have you ever been to a desert? Some deserts are incredibly filled with life and diversity. It's no forest or prairie, but life finds a way. Desert by definition is someplace that gets little rainfall and lacks as much vegetation as other areas.

This is clearly not true in the desert.

I have lived near deserts/semi-deserts, they are desolate and miserable places where some life survives despite all odds. Keeping a small number of national parks as deserts is of course important, but that does not need to be more than 1% of the area that is taken by deserts today.

Wetlands and desert are hardly the same thing.

I would say that e.g. Panoche Hills could be considered a desert environment and it's just a bit down I-5.

I do apologise. According to the standards, it's officially classified as a "Semi-desert" or "Semi-arid climate" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semi-arid_climate

S/he means desert
next

Legal | privacy