Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

All? No thanks. I'll take my life as it is and live it the best I can rather than to live for promises of eternity that most likely are nonsense. It's perfectly possible to find balance in your life without religion, which destroys as often as it heals.


sort by: page size:

Religion is absolutely not the only solution.

It's enough to just realize and come to terms with the fact that life eventually ends, and make sure to have fun while it lasts. Especially when the alternative is religion.


Religion devalues the human life. So what wrong with dying, everyone will have an afterlife anyway.

A happy life and religion are not mutually exclusive. Oh the horror of controlling your impulses and donating a little bit of money.

Avoiding taking sides in religious wars and understanding there are no solutions, only tradeoffs.

Given that religion preys on people’s fear and vulnerabilities, I don’t see why not. It’s a form of abuse.

Perhaps with that bleak and inevitable scenario we'd be all much better off by shooting ourselves now.

Somehow, there seems to be something intrinsic to life that prevents that from happening.

Whether that's a good or bad thing has been endlessly pondered over since the beginning of human cognition—thus the dogged persistence of religion which offers a way out of that depressing inevitability.


I've been told that without religion we'd have no morals.

No, abolish religion.

Ultimately all you can do is gently guide the world toward secular humanism, as people raised under the irrational tribalism of any religion struggle to writhe out of the pit they were born in. Calling out the faults of one flavor of religion is silly.

Some religious people say if there's no god, they will go kill all people. Is such truth worth the price?

Not sure how ending religion would be better for the world. There are some religious fanatics, always will be, that will use their religion to bring about hate and violence. However there are billions of people who practice some form of religion that are peaceful people who use their religion to spread love and peace throughout the world. Don't try to throw the baby out with the bath water. Religious freedom is a cornerstone of a viable democracy.

This is great. I’ve dismissed my Jewish heritage and the teachings of religious texts, but this perspective gives me pause. Maybe I’ve been hasty in my assessment that religion doesn’t offer me anything for making a better future.

Neither statement is true. You can’t fanatic your way out of a weak economic base for long and plenty of non-religious people live happy fulfilling lives.

Most humans seem to need religion. Fighting religion is therefore futile.

Better to fight extremism, and not only the religious type.


I was happier when I was religious. That's the main reason I've considered going back to it. Couldn't do it :(

No I am totally against it. I was qualifying the statement because I couldn't speak to the mindset of someone trapped in that downward spiral.

Religion has had effects in either direction, I wouldn't make any definitive claim on its overall impact. I just think it has a place.


This is a thorny issue.

On the one hand, we're weighting supernatural beliefs against real life-saving treatments. On the other hand, the backlash we can get from some religious people is just as real. God will never smite me, but his followers might.

More generally, I'd say this is not the right way to combat religion. There are reasons why we still have religions, some of them worth copying (helping your neighbour and such), some of them worth combating (such as fear and poverty). Going directly against he will of religious people is only going to get ugly.


I disagree. Christianity, at least, is healthier when it embraces uncertainty.

Living in a cosmological fantasy doesn't give your life meaning.

Mass delusion isn't direction.

Religion uses the facade of "values" to cover up it's core insanity, and sweep it's centuries of war mongering under the rug.

I agree that raising a family makes your life more fulfilling and meaningful. After all, reproduction is arguably the "meaning" of life.

But, raising children in a religion that warps their concept of reality is child abuse.

next

Legal | privacy