Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Sadly, not anymore - used to be the case quite a while ago, but not today anymore as the ads come from the same domains the videos are streamed from.

Those simpler popover-ads which can be closed clicking an X in the upper right corner still are blocked tho...

Spilling my secret tho (and YouTube execs hate me for it!): i block YouTube in my mind and only rarely go to it if i really need to watch a video (which, for me, is rarer than i ever thought it'd be).



sort by: page size:

Do ad-blockers now also block video-ads in youtube?

Youtube still certainly does, from ads played before users without ad blockers can watch the videos.

Can ad blockers block ads on YouTube?

Are they? I block ads on YouTube and I’m still allowed watch videos.

I suspect they have silently stopped blocking ad blockers.

I remember there was a lot of reports about this being the case, but there is no way I am not blocking Google.


It seems to me there are three options available when it comes to YouTube. One can allow the ads to play, block them, or pay for a subscription.

I've never not blocked online advertisements.


Yes.

If you browse YouTube on mobile via the Brave browser it blocks all YouTube ads.

I haven't used the YouTube app in a year...


Unfortunately I watch YouTube on a smart TV. I have no way of blocking their adverts. I can only wait for skip button and skip.

Nope, YouTube blocks some videos from being played and I'm not getting around those in any way. Some videos have ads in them that come up from the bottom, those are preserved and not touched.

There are ads on YouTube? Not for me, which I take as a sign that my ad blocking methods are working

Yes, largely. There was a time where you had to force refresh the filter lists every day or so, but I haven’t had to for a while now.

Ublock Origin will be your best bet against Youtube ads, apart from just paying of course.


Looking at the code, this seems to not block ads but redirect the browser to youtube.com. which in the past did not show ads.

As far as I know, this trick does not work anymore.


Slightly OT, but is youtube even usable without an ad blocker?

Occasionally I make the mistake of going to it in a browser without aggressive ad blocking and it's miserable.


Apparently not, since you're still seeing ads on Youtube. Which adblocker are you even using that doesn't block those?

Sort of, it’d be tough though. YouTube ads aren’t blocked because they’re not using a third party ad vendor. They’re big enough that they run their own auctions. The vast majority of services aren’t capable of creating the auction themselves, so their ads can be blocked.

No, I meant the ads injected by Youtube before the video that cannot be skipped. Those are completely removed by uBlock origin.

I'm not too bothered by sponsored segments in the videos themselves. If they annoy me a couple of right arrow presses are enough to skip them.


Not with the YouTube app, but with the browser, you somewhat can.

I used adguard and it works for like 80 to 90% of the time. For the time where ad did show up, I just reload the page and it is gone.


Actually, no. > they are served from the same inscrutable urls as real video

This may be right, so host based adblocking may not work.

However, uBlock origin etc definitely block youtube ads and it works as a browser extension so they have access to the DOM and probably do something there.


I have one of those but I can't seem to block them effectively. I think the advert URLs are not specific to adverts, ie they're the same as normal YouTube videos.

Any tips??


They don't do that on YouTube but they do something similar on other platforms. Though instead of having different videos they just stitch the ads into the front of the video so you can't block them without blocking the content.
next

Legal | privacy